Politics

Trump News Today: Kim Meeting Never Happened in China

The trump news today out of Asia carried an ending that had been building all week: President Donald Trump flew home from China on Thursday without meeting North Korean leader Kim Jong Un, closing the book on days of speculation that the two men might sit down together on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation summit. Trump confirmed the outcome himself in a telephone interview with NBC News as Air Force One carried him back to Washington, telling reporter Gabe Gutierrez that the relationship between the two leaders remains intact but that no meeting took place. "The relationship is there, but we didn't meet," Trump said, according to NBC. "There was too many meetings. It wouldn't have worked out." He added a promise that has now been repeated for months: "We'll have that meeting at some point."

The announcement landed with a thud after a week in which the possibility of a Trump-Kim encounter had dominated coverage of the president's Asia trip. Trump himself had raised the idea before leaving Washington on Monday, telling reporters he might meet Kim in China and that the two had a chance to accomplish a great deal. Secretary of State Marco Rubio, travelling with the president, described the push for a meeting as a serious idea and said Trump was prepared for dialogue with Pyongyang. Betting markets moved sharply on the suggestion. But Pyongyang never responded publicly to any of it, and by the time Trump boarded his plane in Shenzhen on Thursday, the answer was clear. Kim had not travelled to China at all. Instead, North Korean state media spent the week showing its leader on a tour of construction sites and a naval university on the country's eastern coast, hundreds of miles from Shenzhen and in the opposite direction from the summit.

For Trump, the non-meeting is a setback for one of the most personal projects of his presidency: the revival of a relationship with Kim that produced three face-to-face encounters in his first term and none since 2019. For Kim, the decision to stay home looks deliberate, and analysts who study North Korea say it reveals a great deal about how Pyongyang now sees its position. The North Korean leader, they argue, has little to gain from a meeting Washington has not prepared for, and a great deal to lose from one that goes wrong. He is also, for the first time in his rule, in a position where his ties to Beijing and Moscow are delivering real benefits, and he does not need Washington to get what he wants.

Advertisement

White House News: Trump Confirms the Meeting Never Happened

The confirmation came in the air, on the way home. Trump spoke to NBC's Gabe Gutierrez by telephone as Air Force One flew back to Washington from Shenzhen, and the network reported his account within hours. Trump said he has a good relationship with Kim, but that a meeting did not come together this time because the summit schedule was too crowded. The explanation was brief and practical: too many meetings, no room for another one. It was also, in its own way, a sign of how far the idea had travelled without ever becoming a plan. A meeting between two heads of state normally takes weeks or months of preparation, with teams of officials working out the agenda, the venue, the security and the choreography. There was no public sign that any of that work had been done, and no indication that the two sides had agreed on anything at all, including whether Kim would even be in China.

Trump's trip itself had been crowded by any measure. He began the week at a regional summit in the Philippines, then flew to Shenzhen for the APEC gathering, where he held a bilateral meeting with Chinese President Xi Jinping and took part in the first three-way summit ever held between the leaders of the United States, China and Russia. That meeting with Xi and Putin lasted roughly 80 minutes, according to reports, and it dominated the final day of the trip. Trump left China on Thursday without speaking to reporters on the ground, and the White House said he would hold a news conference on the results of the Asia trip at noon on Friday, November 20.

The rumours had outrun the facts all week. At one point, members of the travelling White House press corps reported that their phones had been taken away as they left China, for security reasons, and the episode set off speculation that Trump might be making an unannounced stop in North Korea. The fact that such a visit seemed plausible at all says something about how Trump's relationship with Kim has evolved. In 2019, a similarly improvised encounter at the Korean Demilitarized Zone grew out of a single message Trump posted on social media while travelling in Japan. This time there was no message, no stop and no meeting. The phones were returned, the plane flew on to Washington, and the speculation dissolved.

Advertisement

Kim's Four-Day Tour: The East Coast Instead of Shenzhen

If there was any doubt about where Kim stood on the idea of a meeting, the North Korean leader supplied an answer of his own, in the form of a travel schedule. According to the Korean Central News Agency, which reported the details on Thursday, Kim spent four consecutive days on a domestic inspection tour that took him steadily away from China rather than toward it. He began on Sunday and Monday by inspecting tourism development projects in Samjiyon, in Ryanggang Province near the Chinese border. Then, on Tuesday and Wednesday, he visited construction sites in Riwon and Rakwon counties in South Hamgyong Province, on the country's eastern coast. On Wednesday he also inspected Kim Jong Suk Naval University in the eastern coastal city of Hamhung.

The geography mattered. The eastern coast is the far side of North Korea from China, and a leader who intended to slip across the border to Shenzhen would not spend the week touring naval colleges and building sites there. Analysts read the itinerary as a message in itself: a public, visible demonstration that Kim was busy at home and had no intention of travelling. It was, in the words of one expert, a nonverbal rejection, delivered in the only language Pyongyang uses when it wants to say no without saying it out loud.

Lim Eul-chul, a professor at Kyungnam University's Institute for Far Eastern Studies, said it was reasonable to interpret Kim's unusual visits to areas near the Chinese border and then to South Hamgyong Province during the APEC summit as a deliberate signal that he would not be swayed by Trump's overtures. From North Korea's perspective, Lim said, strengthening its traditional alliances with Russia and China and expanding practical benefits on several fronts is a far safer and more rewarding strategy at this stage than meeting Trump, which carries considerable risks. He added that the absence of meaningful changes in Washington's policy toward Pyongyang, and the lack of sufficient and credible preliminary arrangements, made an immediate summit less attractive to the North Korean leader. Lim did not rule out talks entirely. He suggested Kim could be deliberately feigning indifference in order to heighten Trump's impatience and strengthen his own bargaining position ahead of any future negotiations.

Advertisement

Why Kim Stayed Away: The Experts' Reading

The expert consensus forming around Kim's decision is that he simply does not need a meeting with Trump right now, and that the terms on offer do not justify the risk. That was the conclusion of Victor Cha and Sydney Seiler, two of Washington's most experienced North Korea watchers, in a discussion on the Center for Strategic and International Studies' Capital Cable programme. Their argument was blunt: Kim's ties with China and Russia are going well, and Pyongyang sent delegations to Beijing and Moscow before the APEC summit to explain why it would not be coming. Trump, they noted, had left an open invitation on the table with no conditions attached, and Kim still did not show up.

The logic of the position is straightforward. North Korea has spent the past several years deepening its relationships with its two neighbours, and those relationships are now delivering tangible benefits: trade, energy, diplomatic cover and a measure of protection from international pressure. A meeting with Trump, by contrast, would offer little that Kim cannot already get elsewhere, and it would carry real dangers. A summit that produced nothing would be an embarrassment. A summit that produced a bad outcome, with Kim seen to have conceded something, would be worse. And a summit held on terms set by Washington would hand Trump the photograph he wants while giving Kim nothing in return.

The deeper obstacle is the one that has blocked every attempt at dialogue since the last summit collapsed: the nuclear question. North Korea has said repeatedly that it will not resume discussions unless the goal of denuclearisation is taken off the agenda. In a speech to the Supreme People's Assembly on September 21, Kim said there would be no reason for the two sides not to face each other if the United States abandoned its demand that the North give up its nuclear weapons. That is a position Washington and its allies have refused to accept, and it is the central obstacle to any renewed engagement. Since the last summit, North Korea has pressed ahead with its weapons programme, enshrining its nuclear status in law and declaring its arsenal permanent and irreversible, even as years of United Nations sanctions have continued. Other analysts have added that sanctions are no longer the lever they once were, because Pyongyang has learned to live with them, which makes an American offer of relief worth far less than it was in 2019.

Advertisement

Trump Administration: A Week of Hype Before the Trip

The speculation that ended in disappointment had been building for months, and it reached its peak in the days before Trump left Washington. The president has said repeatedly throughout his second term that he wants to meet Kim again, and in August he said he planned to do so within the year. That remark set off the first round of speculation about a meeting on the sidelines of the APEC summit, and the rumours intensified as the trip approached. On Monday, the day he departed, Trump raised the possibility himself, telling reporters at the White House that he would meet Xi and Putin and might meet Kim as well. "We may meet with Kim Jong Un also. So that'll be good. We have a chance to accomplish a lot," he said. The following day, he left the possibility open again, saying Kim "would like to" attend the APEC summit, and adding that Kim's attendance was ultimately up to Xi, as host of the gathering.

The markets reacted as they always do to a Trump hint. The odds of Trump and Kim meeting before the end of the year rose to 18 percent on Polymarket, the prediction market, up 13 percentage points in a single day. That is still a long way from a likely outcome, and prediction markets measure what traders think rather than what will happen, but the size and speed of the move showed how seriously the idea was being taken. A report by Russia's Interfax news agency added fuel, quoting the Kremlin as saying that a meeting between Kim and Putin was possible if the North Korean leader attended the summit in Shenzhen. Analysts read that as a signal about Kim's movements, because Moscow would have little reason to talk publicly about a Putin-Kim encounter unless it expected Kim to be in Shenzhen in the first place.

The Trump administration's own messaging was mixed. Rubio, travelling with the president, said the push for a summit was a serious idea and that the president was prepared for dialogue with Pyongyang. But the White House never said whether any preparations for a meeting were under way, and neither China nor North Korea confirmed anything. China's Foreign Ministry, the North Korean embassy in Beijing and APEC itself did not immediately respond to requests for comment. That silence was normal for all three, and it told us little on its own. What it meant was that the public record consisted of Trump's remarks, the Kremlin's statement and the reading of those remarks by analysts and by the markets. None of it amounted to evidence that a meeting was actually being arranged.

Advertisement

Donald Trump Latest News: Three Summits, Seven Years Apart

The story of Trump and Kim is one of the most unusual personal relationships in modern diplomacy, and its history explains why the prospect of a fourth meeting generated so much attention. The two men met three times during Trump's first term: in Singapore in June 2018, in Hanoi in February 2019, and at the inter-Korean border village of Panmunjom later the same year. The Singapore meeting was the first ever between a sitting American president and a North Korean leader. The Hanoi summit ended without agreement, after the two sides failed to bridge the gap between Kim's demand for sanctions relief and Washington's demand for steps toward giving up nuclear weapons. The Panmunjom encounter was the most improvised of all: it grew out of a message Trump posted on social media while leaving Japan, inviting Kim to meet him at the border simply to shake his hand, and Kim rushed to the village for a brief summit.

Since that day in 2019, the two men have not met face to face, and the world around them has changed. North Korea has expanded its nuclear arsenal and deepened its ties with Russia and China. The United States has changed presidents twice and returned to Trump. And the near misses have accumulated. Similar expectations surrounded Trump's visit to South Korea in October of last year, when Kim stopped all public activity for five days, from October 25 to 29, prompting speculation that he needed time for political deliberation before a decision about a summit. He reappeared only after Trump had left the country. During a parliamentary intelligence briefing on November 4 of last year, South Korea's National Intelligence Service reported that Pyongyang had seriously considered a last-minute summit with Trump. Hopes faded again during Trump's trip to Beijing in May of this year, when a meeting was discussed and never materialised.

For the countries watching from the sidelines, the stakes are high. South Korean President Lee Jae Myung has said he hopes Trump can persuade Kim to resume dialogue, and South Korea's Unification Ministry said it had nothing to confirm when asked about Kim's possible trip to Shenzhen. Japan's Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi has repeatedly sought a summit of her own with Kim to resolve the long-running issue of Japanese nationals abducted by North Korea in the 1970s and 1980s, and Pyongyang has rebuffed Tokyo's approaches. Both governments will have watched this week's events with a mixture of relief and frustration: relief that no deal was struck over their heads, and frustration that the door to dialogue remains closed.

Advertisement

What Happens Next

The immediate answer is that Trump will address the trip himself. The White House has scheduled a news conference for noon on Friday, November 20, at which the president is expected to discuss the results of the Asia trip, including the three-way meeting with Xi and Putin and the bilateral talks with Xi. Whether he says anything new about Kim remains to be seen, but the question will certainly be asked, and the president's answer will be watched closely in Seoul, Tokyo and Pyongyang. Trump has shown, across two terms, that he does not abandon an idea simply because it fails once. He has now said three times in the space of a week that a meeting with Kim will happen at some point, and his record suggests he means it.

The deeper question is whether the conditions for a meeting will ever be right. On the American side, the obstacle is preparation: a summit announced before it is negotiated risks repeating the failure of Hanoi, where the two leaders arrived with incompatible expectations and left with nothing. On the North Korean side, the obstacle is incentive: Kim has made clear, through his words and through his actions this week, that he will not come to the table unless Washington is prepared to change its position on the nuclear question. That is a change no American president has been willing to make, and there is no sign that this one will be the exception.

For now, the pattern is set. Trump will keep the invitation open, Kim will keep his distance, and the analysts will keep watching the small signals: a delegation to Beijing, a pause in public appearances, a tour of the eastern coast that takes the leader in the opposite direction from the summit. The meeting that was supposed to happen in Shenzhen did not happen, and the two men who have not sat down together in seven years will have to wait a little longer. Whether they meet at all, and on what terms, is a question that will outlast this trip, and it will be answered not by a message on social media or a remark on Air Force One, but by the slow work of negotiation that neither side has yet shown any sign of beginning.

Advertisement

Source: France 24

Advertisement

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Advertisement
Advertisement
About Us  |  Contact Us  |  Privacy Policy  |  Disclaimer  |  Terms and Conditions