Politics

Trump Executive Orders: Union Pacts Face Legal Fight

President Donald Trump's executive orders cancelling union contracts across the federal workforce have run into the most sustained legal resistance of his second term, with judges, a federal labour board and the unions themselves all pushing back against the most far-reaching attack on collective bargaining in the federal government in nearly fifty years. The trump executive orders at the centre of the fight strip roughly a million federal workers of their right to bargain collectively, on the grounds that their jobs touch national security. The unions say the orders are a pretext for retaliation against organisations that have challenged the administration, and the courts have repeatedly agreed with them, at least in part. In the latest setback for the administration, the Federal Labor Relations Authority ruled in October that a union contract at the Department of Agriculture remains binding, because the agency failed to follow the law when it tried to cancel it. The ruling is a small case about a single office in Oregon, but it captures the larger story: a strategy built on sweeping executive power is being tested, clause by clause, in courtrooms and hearing rooms across the country.

The fight began on the evening of March 27, 2025, when Trump signed an executive order directing dozens of federal agencies and offices to terminate their union contracts. The order, Executive Order 14251, relied on a little-used provision of the 1978 Civil Service Reform Act, which allows the president to exclude employees whose work directly affects national security from the federal labour relations system. The administration paired the order with a federal lawsuit filed in Texas the same day, asking a court to affirm that the agencies could terminate their existing collective bargaining agreements. The unions promised to challenge the order in court, as they had challenged the president's decision to fire tens of thousands of their members and weaken their job protections. Bloomberg Law reported at the time that the order was ripe for legal challenge, and the nineteen months since have proved that judgment right.

The Orders That Started the Fight

Executive Order 14251, titled "Exclusions from Federal Labor-Management Relations Programs," invoked the president's authority under 5 U.S.C. section 7103(b)(1) to exclude designated agencies and subdivisions from the Federal Service Labor-Management Relations Statute. The statute is the law that gives federal workers the right to organise and bargain collectively, and the exclusion power was designed for a narrow purpose: to keep collective bargaining out of agencies whose primary functions involve intelligence, counterintelligence, investigative or national security work, where applying the statute would be inconsistent with national security requirements. Presidents Jimmy Carter and Ronald Reagan each used the same 1978 law to exclude smaller portions of the government workforce from federal labour protections. Trump's order was different in scale. It initially targeted more than thirty agencies, including those dealing with defence, border security, foreign relations, energy security, pandemic preparedness, cybersecurity and public safety, and the administration argued that eighteen different departments had sufficient national security roles to qualify.

Advertisement

A second order, Executive Order 14343, issued on August 28, 2025, expanded the exclusions further, adding entities such as NASA, the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration and the National Weather Service. The rationale, as the White House explained it, was that labour contracts can interfere with national security operations and with management's ability to implement necessary changes. The fact sheet released with the March order was blunter. It said that unions had "declared war" on the president's agenda, and that while Trump supported "constructive partnerships with unions who work with him," he would "not tolerate mass obstruction." The administration's critics seized on that language. They argued that the orders were not really about national security at all, but about punishing unions that had opposed the administration's policies, and that the choice of agencies gave the game away: the order touched workers who are not clearly involved in national security at all, such as those who evaluate drug applications, administer veterans' benefits and inspect food products.

The scope of the action is what makes it legally vulnerable, according to the lawyers who have challenged it. To exempt an agency from union rights, the statute requires the president to determine that its primary functions include intelligence, counterintelligence, investigative or national security work, and that the labour statute cannot be applied to the agency in a way that is consistent with national security needs. Allen Shoikhetbrod, an attorney at Tully Rinckey, told Bloomberg Law that the scope of Trump's action was much broader than Ronald Reagan's, potentially covering hundreds of thousands of workers, and that the rationale for many of the selections was questionable. The administration, for its part, has argued that the president has authority under Article II of the Constitution to direct the executive branch as he sees fit, including reducing headcount, without being restrained by government unions. Jacob Huebert, an attorney and president of the Liberty Justice Center, which argued successfully at the US Supreme Court to ban mandatory union dues for government employees in Janus v. AFSCME, has made that case for the administration's side.

The Courts Push Back

The unions moved quickly. On April 3, 2025, six unions filed suit: the American Federation of Government Employees, the American Federation of State, County, and Municipal Employees, the National Association of Government Employees, the National Federation of Federal Employees, National Nurses United and the Service Employees International Union, who collectively represent more than 950,000 federal employees. The suit challenged the March executive order, and the Office of Personnel Management's guidance telling agencies to end union rights and union contracts, shut down grievance procedures and continue the president's reduction-in-force programme while ignoring the reduction-in-force requirements in the cancelled contracts. It was the opening move in a legal campaign that has now produced rulings in several courts, with the unions winning most of the early rounds.

Advertisement

The first major victory for the unions came in June 2025, when US District Judge James Donato granted the American Federation of Government Employees and its allies a preliminary injunction, ruling that the executive order was very likely illegal. In a 29-page order, Judge Donato concluded that the order was very likely a retaliatory attempt to punish federal employee unions for engaging in constitutionally protected speech, citing the unions' lawsuits against the administration's government-efficiency programme and a webpage cataloguing their actions. He also pointed to the fact sheet the administration released with the executive order, which expressed anti-union views, as "solid evidence of a tie between the exercise of First Amendment rights and a government sanction." The decision blocked the order until the lawsuit was resolved, and the union called it a crucial victory for federal workers and the rule of law.

The Department of Veterans Affairs has become the most contested front in the fight. The VA, which employs more than 300,000 workers covered by a collective bargaining agreement with the American Federation of Government Employees, moved last year to terminate the contract in light of the president's order. On Friday, August 7, 2026, US District Judge Melissa DuBose in Providence, Rhode Island, ruled for the third time that the VA could not terminate the agreement. Judge DuBose granted the union's motion to enforce her earlier injunction, rejecting the VA's argument that the agreement's August 8 expiration date released the agency from its obligations. She pointed to a provision in the contract that automatically extends its terms while negotiations for a new agreement are underway, finding that its terms were "explained, in plain and unambiguous detail," and that negotiations had begun well within the required period, making the VA's plan to treat the agreement as defunct "in direct contravention" of her prior order. The contract covers 320,000 employees, and the ruling was another blow to the administration's efforts to strip federal workers of collective bargaining rights.

Judge DuBose had first ordered the VA to reinstate the agreement earlier in the year, finding that the union was likely to show the agency cancelled it in retaliation for the union's opposition to the administration's labour policies. She then ruled later in March that the VA had flouted her decision by attempting to terminate the contract a second time. The third attempt, built on the expiration-date argument, failed for the same reason the first two had: the judge found that the agency was trying to do by procedure what it had been forbidden to do by substance. The case, American Federation of Government Employees Local 2305 v. U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs, is one of at least three lawsuits challenging the executive order directly, while unions have filed many more challenges to individual agencies cancelling their bargaining agreements.

Advertisement

The Labour Board Draws a Line

While the courts were dealing with the big questions, the Federal Labor Relations Authority, the body that governs federal employee unions, was dealing with the details, and in October it handed the unions two significant wins. In a decision issued on October 26, 2026, the authority ruled that a newly negotiated collective bargaining agreement at the Department of Agriculture was binding, despite the agency's attempt to disapprove it. The case concerned the USDA's Oregon Rural Development office and the National Federation of Federal Employees, Federal Lodge 7, which had executed a new agreement on February 27, 2026. Under the law, the head of a federal agency generally has thirty days to review a negotiated agreement and approve or disapprove it, and must properly notify the union of any disapproval, as required by 5 U.S.C. section 7114(c) and the authority's own regulations. The agency failed to do so. The authority concluded that the agreement became effective and binding on March 30, 2026, thirty-one days after the parties executed it.

The ruling, NFFE Federal Lodge 7 and USDA Oregon Rural Development, 74 FLRA No. 88, illustrates an important distinction in federal labour relations today. While the president's executive orders have removed collective bargaining rights from numerous agencies, other federal organisations remain subject to the federal labour relations statute, and the procedures that protect negotiated agreements still apply to them. The decision does not mean every provision of the agreement is enforceable: the authority emphasised that contract provisions conflicting with federal law or applicable regulations may still be challenged in grievance arbitration and unfair labour practice cases. But it establishes that an agency cannot simply ignore the statute's procedures when it wants a contract to disappear. An email, the authority found, was not enough.

Five days earlier, on October 21, 2026, the authority had upheld an arbitration award against the Department of Health and Human Services for cancelling telework. The case raised a question that matters to thousands of federal employees who lost telework and remote-work arrangements after Trump's January 2025 return-to-office directive: can a presidential directive override a union contract that protects telework? At HHS, the answer was no. The authority upheld an arbitrator's ruling that the department could not disregard its negotiated agreement simply because the president had directed agencies to bring employees back to the office. The agreement, negotiated in July 2023, set procedures for employee participation in telework and remote-work programmes, and while it allowed the department to end or change telework arrangements for cause, including for performance, misconduct, eligibility or operational reasons, the arbitrator found that the department had violated it by cancelling telework without following the negotiated procedures. The return-to-office memorandum itself requires agencies to carry it out "consistent with applicable law," and one such law makes it an unfair labour practice for an agency to enforce a new rule that conflicts with a collective bargaining agreement already in effect.

Advertisement

The HHS decision also carried an embarrassing footnote for the department. The authority criticised the department's legal brief, noting that 22 of its 29 footnotes and 35 of its 42 legal or record citations were fictitious, erroneous or irrelevant, and said the nature and scope of the errors suggested the possible use of a generative artificial intelligence tool. It was a sharp rebuke, and a reminder that the administration's legal campaign is being fought not only against the unions, but against the standards of the tribunals hearing its cases.

The Administration's Case

The administration has not stood still while the courts have ruled against it. In February 2026, the Office of Personnel Management, under Director Scott Kupor, issued a new directive ordering agencies covered by the two executive orders to terminate or modify their collective bargaining agreements. The memorandum, released on February 12, 2026, explicitly advised covered entities to "proceed to terminate or modify Collective Bargaining Agreements (CBAs) in order to fully comply" with Executive Order 14251 and Executive Order 14343, and required agencies to report their compliance every month. Kupor has made no secret of the administration's philosophy: the government wants to make significant changes in the federal workforce, and it is not accepting of a mindset that believes "if it ain't broke, don't fix it."

The administration's fortunes in court improved in August this year, when a panel of the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals agreed to the administration's request to lift the last of several lower court injunctions that had broadly blocked implementation of the March order. The panel rejected the unions' arguments that the order and the accompanying fact sheet blaming "hostile" unions for trying to "obstruct agency management" were evidence of its true aim. Even accepting, for purposes of argument, that certain statements in the fact sheet reflected a degree of retaliatory animus toward the unions' First Amendment activities, the court determined, the fact sheet taken as a whole also demonstrated the president's focus on national security. In the two weeks after the injunctions were lifted, the administration quietly terminated collective bargaining agreements at the Department of Veterans Affairs, the Environmental Protection Agency, the USDA Food Safety and Inspection Service, the US Coast Guard, US Citizenship and Immigration Services and the Federal Emergency Management Agency. More cancellations were expected.

Advertisement

But the reprieve was partial. Days after the 9th Circuit ruling, a lower court judge sided with the Federal Education Association, granting an injunction that would bar any termination of union contracts at the Department of Education. The court battles on the executive order are still continuing on the merits, and the unions acknowledge they are facing a setback and must rethink aspects of their strategy for survival under Trump. Everett Kelley, president of the American Federation of Government Employees, the largest federal employee union, has said the unions will keep fighting the order in court and in Congress, where they are hopeful that a discharge petition could force the House to take a vote on a bill that would overturn the March order.

What Happens Next

The legal fight over the union contracts is far from over, and its outcome will shape the federal workforce for years. The cases challenging the March 2025 order are still working their way through the courts on the merits, and the questions they raise, about the scope of the president's power under the 1978 statute, about retaliation against constitutionally protected speech, and about the limits of executive authority over the civil service, are the kind that the Supreme Court may eventually have to answer. The 9th Circuit's decision to lift the injunctions does not resolve those questions; it decides only that the order can be implemented while the litigation continues. The unions' victories in the district courts, and at the Federal Labor Relations Authority, suggest that the administration will keep losing individual battles even as it wins procedural ones.

Congress may yet have a say. The unions are pressing for a discharge petition that would force the House to vote on legislation overturning the March order, and the new Democratic majorities arriving in January will be more sympathetic to that effort than the outgoing Republican Congress. Whether a bill could pass the Senate, or survive a presidential veto, is another matter, but the political landscape has shifted in the unions' favour since the midterm elections, and the administration knows it.

Advertisement

There is also the question of the Federal Labor Relations Authority itself. Ernie DuBester, the former Democratic chairman of the authority's board, told Bloomberg Law that the Trump administration was trying to paralyse the authority, and the October rulings in the USDA and HHS cases show why that matters: the authority is one of the few institutions still holding the administration to the letter of the labour law.

For the roughly one million federal workers whose bargaining rights are at stake, the fight is not abstract. It determines whether they can negotiate over telework, over grievance procedures, over the terms of their employment, or whether those questions are decided unilaterally by agency heads acting on presidential orders. The trump executive orders were designed to settle that question quickly and decisively, in the administration's favour. Nineteen months later, the question is still open, and the courts, the labour board and the unions are still answering it, one case at a time.

Source: Bloomberg Law

Advertisement
Advertisement

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Advertisement
Advertisement
About Us  |  Contact Us  |  Privacy Policy  |  Disclaimer  |  Terms and Conditions