Politics

Trump Administration Law Firm Deals Face Reckoning

In the spring of 2025, nine of America's most powerful law firms made a bargain with the Trump administration that stunned the legal profession. Facing presidential orders that threatened to strip them of access to federal buildings, government contracts and security clearances, the firms promised a combined 940 million dollars in free legal work for causes backed by the White House. Eighteen months later, that safety is gone. Democrats swept both chambers of Congress in the midterm elections, and the firms that signed now face subpoenas, compelled testimony and the public disclosure of exactly what they agreed to do.

The turning point arrived in a letter. On November 5, two days after the midterm elections, Kirkland & Ellis, the largest law firm in the world by revenue, told three senior Democrats that it had already provided at least 11.8 million dollars in free legal services to federal agencies and government-backed entities. Within two weeks, the lawmakers had denounced the arrangement as a corrupt bargain, demanded records from the other firms, and made clear that the investigation would intensify once Democrats take control of Congress in January.

Congress: Democrats Demand Answers From Nine Firms

The latest chapter opened on November 19, when Representative Jamie Raskin, the ranking Democrat on the House Judiciary Committee, joined Senators Richard Blumenthal and Adam Schiff in accusing the firms of stonewalling a congressional inquiry that began in April 2025. The three lawmakers said they had received substantial and profoundly troubling information showing that the bargain went much further than originally understood, and they sent follow-up letters to nine firms demanding records about their agreements with the White House.

Advertisement

The letters went to Latham & Watkins, Simpson Thacher & Bartlett, Willkie Farr & Gallagher, Sullivan & Cromwell, Hogan Lovells Cadwalader, A&O Shearman, Milbank, Paul, Weiss, and Skadden. The lawmakers said the vast majority of the firms have yet to provide any substantive answers or turn over a single responsive document.

Democrats won control of the House of Representatives and the Senate in the midterm elections, and from January they will hold the gavels on the committees that can issue subpoenas, compel witnesses and demand documents from private companies as well as government agencies. The firms, which spent the past year largely ignoring Democratic letters that carried no legal force, will no longer have that option. The pressure is already changing behaviour: the Financial Times reported that some firms have hired outside lawyers to prepare, with Skadden enlisting a former special counsel to former President Joe Biden.

What Kirkland & Ellis Told Lawmakers

Kirkland & Ellis is the firm that broke the silence, and its letter offers the clearest window yet into what the deals involved. The letter, signed by attorney Beth Wilkinson, said Kirkland had provided more than 6,400 hours of free legal work valued at 11.8 million dollars to federal agencies, plus additional pro bono work that brought its total under the deal to more than 18.7 million dollars across 15,469 hours by the end of September.

Advertisement

Kirkland said it performed about 4 million dollars of work for the Commerce Department, 2.2 million dollars for the Defense Department, 1.6 million dollars for the Postal Service, and 2 million dollars for the United States International Development Finance Corporation. It also did 1.8 million dollars of free work representing an investment entity created under a memorandum of understanding between the United States and Japan to build a 550 billion dollar investment fund. The letter did not describe the exact nature of the work, and the lawmakers said that gap was itself a reason to keep digging.

Just as revealing is what Kirkland said it refused to do. The firm turned down administration requests to work on renaming the John F. Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts, on supporting the construction of the president's triumphal arch in Washington, on census matters, on the programme known as Trump Accounts, and on challenges to the Postal Service's handling of mail ballots. The lawmakers seized on those refusals, arguing that they raise serious questions about whether other firms acceded to demands that Kirkland rejected.

Kirkland's letter also explained how it came to the table: it began negotiating after Skadden reached its own deal in March 2025, and after the administration threatened it with an Equal Employment Opportunity Commission investigation and the kind of retributive executive order already levelled against other firms. The account paints a picture of a firm acting under direct threat rather than enthusiasm, a distinction its defenders are likely to stress when the hearings begin.

Advertisement

White House News: How the Deals Were Struck in Spring 2025

The story begins in the spring of 2025, when the Trump administration launched an unprecedented campaign against the legal profession. It began with a presidential memorandum in February 2025 targeting Covington & Burling, which had done pro bono work for Jack Smith, the prosecutor who led criminal investigations into the president before the 2024 election. A string of executive orders followed, each one aimed at a firm the president regarded as an enemy.

Perkins Coie was targeted for its work for Hillary Clinton. Paul, Weiss came under fire for hiring Mark Pomerantz, a lawyer who worked on the Manhattan district attorney's investigation into Trump's finances, and for a lawsuit over the January 6, 2021 riot at the Capitol brought by one of its partners. The orders threatened to strip the firms of security clearances, bar their lawyers from federal buildings, and cut off government contracts, not only for the firms themselves but for any company that used them.

For firms whose business depends on access to government agencies, the threat was existential. Brad Karp, then the chair of Paul, Weiss, told his staff in an email in March 2025 that the president's threats were an existential crisis that could destroy the firm if it lost access to critical government departments. A firm frozen out of government approvals can see a large merger collapse.

Advertisement

One by one, nine firms chose to settle. Paul, Weiss went first, agreeing to provide 40 million dollars in free legal work. Skadden followed with a pledge of more than 100 million dollars. Kirkland & Ellis, Latham & Watkins, Simpson Thacher and A&O Shearman each promised 125 million dollars, while Milbank, Willkie Farr & Gallagher and Cadwalader each pledged 100 million dollars. Between them, the nine firms offered 940 million dollars in free services.

Trump Executive Orders: The Firms That Fought Back in Court

Not every firm capitulated. Four prominent firms, Jenner & Block, WilmerHale, Susman Godfrey and Perkins Coie, sued the White House, arguing that the executive orders were unconstitutional. Federal judges ruled in their favour, and the Justice Department eventually dropped its defence of the orders after the courts repeatedly found them unlawful. The firms that fought won, and the firms that settled were left to explain why they had not fought too.

Hundreds of smaller firms publicly backed Perkins Coie's lawsuit, but the big global firms mostly stayed silent; the United States arm of London-based Freshfields was the only large international firm to put its name to the opposition. Many larger firms quietly reversed their diversity policies and began avoiding pro bono cases in areas such as immigration and transgender rights.

Advertisement

The human cost of the deals was visible from the start. On the evening of March 28, 2025, Brenna Frey, a 41-year-old class-action litigator who had spent the best part of a decade at Skadden, resigned hours after the firm announced its deal. She later said she had sworn an oath to the Constitution when she passed the bar, and felt that what the firm had done prevented her from upholding that oath. She knew no large firm would ever hire her again, and now runs a legal consultancy in Washington, earning far less than she did in big law. Kathleen Rubenstein, an academic fellow at Columbia Law School, stepped down as director of the Skadden Foundation, a non-profit set up by the firm, after its deal. John Relman, founder of the civil rights firm Relman Colfax, said no one has any idea what the firms stayed away from, or what they actually did for the administration.

Senate: The Investigation Gains Subpoena Power in January

The Democrats' investigation has been running since April 2025, when sixteen House Democrats led by Representatives Dave Min and April McClain Delaney wrote to all nine firms suggesting the agreements might implicate bribery and extortion laws. The firms largely ignored the warning. In October, Raskin, Blumenthal and Schiff wrote to Jon Ballis, the chair of Kirkland & Ellis, threatening to use every tool at their disposal. That October letter produced the November disclosure, and the disclosure produced the new round of letters to the other firms.

In the minority, Democrats could only ask. In the majority, they can compel. The Senate's Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations, where Blumenthal serves as ranking member, and the House Judiciary Committee, where Raskin is the ranking member, can demand documents from the firms, the White House and the agencies that received free legal work, and can call firm leaders to testify in public.

Advertisement

The firms' defences are already taking shape. Simpson Thacher wrote to Democrats arguing that the suggestion it may have violated federal law, state law or rules of professional conduct is wholly without merit. Other firms are expected to argue that they preserved their independence, chose which matters to take on, and had a responsibility to protect firms employing thousands of people. Whether that argument survives a public hearing is another matter.

DOJ News: The American Bar Association's Separate Fight

The congressional investigation is not the only legal threat the firms face. Last week, a Washington judge ordered the White House to hand over its communications with the nine firms in a separate legal battle with the American Bar Association, which has accused the administration of trying to intimidate and coerce law firms. The ruling could force the negotiations that produced the deals into the open.

And yet, for all the outrage, many of the firms went on to post record revenues. Kirkland & Ellis had its best-ever year in 2025, with revenues of 10.6 billion dollars and the average profit taken home by its equity partners rising 20 per cent to 11 million dollars. Critics say the firms profited from surrender, while defenders say the profits prove the leadership was right to protect the institution.

Advertisement

What Happens Next: Subpoenas, Testimony and a Profession on Trial

The new Congress convenes in January, and the law firm investigation is expected to be among the first items on the oversight agenda. Firm chairs and the lawyers who negotiated the deals are likely to be the first witnesses called.

For the legal profession, the stakes go beyond any single firm. The deals raised questions about whether the country's most powerful lawyers can be trusted to stand up to a president who threatens them, and whether the promise of free legal work can ever be separated from the power that extracted it. The courts answered one part of that question when they struck down the executive orders. Congress is about to ask the rest of it, in public, under oath.

Source: The Times

Advertisement
Advertisement

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Advertisement
Advertisement
About Us  |  Contact Us  |  Privacy Policy  |  Disclaimer  |  Terms and Conditions