Politics

Senate Confirmation Hearings: Trump GAO Pick No Stooge

The senate confirmation hearings on Thursday produced one of the sharpest exchanges of the lame-duck session, and a single sentence that is likely to follow the nominee for the rest of his career. Eric Ueland, President Donald Trump's pick to lead the Government Accountability Office for a 15-year term, told the Senate Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee that he would not serve as a rubber stamp for the administration he now helps to run. I understand the responsibilities of the comptroller general, he said. And if I am privileged to be confirmed, I will fully discharge those responsibilities. I'm not here as a plant, a stooge, a lackey for anybody. My role and responsibility is to call it as I see it. And that is exactly what I will do if I have the privilege of being confirmed.

Ueland is the deputy director of the White House Office of Management and Budget, and a close ally of its director, Russ Vought. Trump nominated him on Monday, November 16, to head the GAO, the independent watchdog agency that works for Congress and audits the executive branch. If confirmed, Ueland would oversee the agency that has repeatedly found his own office's spending freezes and impoundments unlawful, a conflict that dominated the hearing from its first minutes. The committee concluded its first panel, which included Ueland and six other nominees, in about 40 minutes, but the questioning of Ueland took up most of that time, and Democrats left the room unconvinced.

The stakes of the nomination go well beyond one man's job. The comptroller general serves a 15-year term, longer than any presidency, and the GAO is the institution Congress relies on to police the power of the purse. As of July 2025, the GAO had opened at least 46 investigations into impoundment, the practice of withholding money that Congress has appropriated, and had found in 12 cases that agencies violated the Impoundment Control Act. The OMB, under Vought, has been at the center of those disputes, freezing funds in ways the GAO has ruled unlawful. Trump has said he wants to challenge the law against impoundment, which he calls unconstitutional, and Vought has declined to commit to following it. The question before the committee was whether the man who helped run that office can be trusted to oversee it.

Advertisement

Trump Administration: Democrats Question Ueland's Independence

The sharpest challenge came from Senator Gary Peters of Michigan, the committee's ranking Democrat, who told Ueland that the OMB under the Trump administration has not cooperated with any of the GAO's audit work. It's really problematic that you're going to be the person that's supposed to oversee the administration for Congress, Peters said. How can Congress trust you to run GAO when your agency that you currently help lead is absolutely refusing to cooperate with GAO's oversight? Peters called the GAO part of being the umpire in the constitutional system, and told Ueland directly: You're clearly not that umpire. He also warned that moving ahead with the nomination would do irreversible damage to the GAO.

Senator Maggie Hassan, a New Hampshire Democrat who is expected to chair the committee when Democrats take control of Congress in January, raised the same concern in blunter terms. You've been nominated to serve as a watchdog over your current boss for an agency that your boss thinks shouldn't even exist, she said. American taxpayers deserve an independent, nonpartisan watchdog at GAO, which is why Congress put in place a nonpartisan selection process that the White House has chosen to flout in jamming your nomination through the Senate. It is deeply, deeply concerning.

Ueland's account of how he came to be nominated did little to quiet those doubts. According to Hassan, Ueland told the committee in writing the day before the hearing that the director of OMB in passing asked me if it was truly my interest to serve as comptroller general, and I replied, yes, but no discussion occurred. Ueland told the committee that was the extent of his conversation with Vought about the position, and that Vought said essentially nothing after he said he was interested. He also said he had little discussion with his boss about his interest in leading the agency. For senators who wanted evidence that the nomination was the product of an independent process, the casual nature of that exchange was itself an answer.

Advertisement

The process that produced the nomination was the other focus of Democratic criticism. By statute, a 10-member commission recommends at least three candidates for comptroller general to the president after an extensive review and interview process. The last time lawmakers vetted candidates for the job, in 2010, the commission spent more than a year on its search. This time, members of the commission were given 24 hours' notice on a federal holiday to come up with at least three candidates. A committee aide told reporters that Ueland's nomination was preordained by the White House, and that the GAO received his ethics paperwork before the commission produced two other names.

Congress: The Republican Split Over the Nomination

The nomination has also divided Republicans, and that division may decide its fate. Senator Thom Tillis of North Carolina, who is retiring, told reporters he would oppose including Ueland in a group package of nominees, and said he has already issued a presumptive hold if the nomination comes out of committee. I won't allow him to go through en bloc, Tillis said, adding that he thinks the country needs somebody more independent for the office to have credibility. Tillis was careful to say the objection was not personal, telling reporters he would hire Ueland in his own office today. But his hold, if it stands, would force the nomination to a separate vote and slow a confirmation the White House wants finished before Democrats take the Senate in January.

Other Republicans defended the pick. Senator James Lankford of Oklahoma said the White House seems to have followed the letter of the law in nominating Ueland, even if he was not sure about the spirit of the law, and called Ueland a great candidate for the role given his experience at several executive branch agencies and on Capitol Hill. Committee chairman Rand Paul of Kentucky said the selection process for previous comptrollers general has not been fully bipartisan in the past, noting that the commission in 2010 did not reach a final agreement and that Democrats and Republicans sent separate lists, although both included former comptroller general Gene Dodaro.

Advertisement

Outside the hearing room, opposition has been building. Earlier in the week, more than 20 former inspectors general signed a letter opposing Ueland's confirmation, writing that the nomination fails on both counts of independence and process. The committee is expected to hold a vote on whether to advance the nominations in early December, but no specific date has been set, and the lame-duck calendar leaves little room for delay.

Ueland's own pitch to the committee rested on his record at the OMB. He told senators that his work there would be a value-add for the GAO, and that if confirmed he would focus on optimizing the work the agency does, offering blunt, straightforward advice about what might work, what could change for the better, and what truly is not working. He gave the GAO a medium grade so far in reducing fraud, waste and abuse in government, noting that some items on the agency's high-risk list have been stuck there for decades. He touted his role in the administration's push to get more agencies to use the Treasury Department's Do Not Pay dataset. We're responsible at OMB for working with all departments and agencies on their financial management and control systems, he said. Our goal inside the administration that I've worked on is to deliver a clean audit for 2028. The Defense Department failed a financial audit for the ninth year in a row, according to an inspector general report released on Monday.

Trump Cabinet: A Hearing Full of Flashpoints

The hearing was not only about Ueland. Thirteen nominees appeared before the committee in total, including Trump's picks to lead the Department of Homeland Security's cybersecurity agency, the Office of Government Ethics and several agency inspector general offices, and the session produced a series of clashes that showed how contentious the confirmation process has become in the final weeks of the lame-duck Congress.

Advertisement

Michael Chamberlain, the nominee to head the Office of Government Ethics, was pressed by Senator Richard Blumenthal of Connecticut for not agreeing that there was an attack on the Capitol on January 6, 2021. How do you expect to be the chief arbiter and adjudicator of ethics in the United States government when you cannot answer a simple factual question, Blumenthal asked. Do you really want this job? Chamberlain responded that matters before the ethics office would be evaluated in a fair and impartial manner. Blumenthal later contrasted his answers with those of two inspector general nominees. Maria D'Avanzo, nominated to be the watchdog at the General Services Administration, said she honestly did not know the numbers when asked who won the popular vote in 2020, and described January 6 as a chaotic protest rather than an attack. Robert Steinau, who would lead the inspector general's office at NASA, answered that Joe Biden was elected president in 2020 and said he would call January 6 an attack.

Two other inspector general nominees, Mark Priebe at the Education Department and Dennis Kirk at the Interior Department, also testified. Kirk is a co-author of Project 2025, the conservative policy blueprint, and a former Interior inspector general has argued that his political background makes it impossible for him to provide impartial oversight. When all of the nominees were asked who won the popular vote in 2020, Priebe said Joe Biden won the popular vote and was certified to be the president, and Kirk answered that he liked what Priebe said.

What Happens Next

The immediate question is whether Ueland's nomination can survive the Senate. The committee is expected to vote on advancing the nominations in early December, but Tillis's presumptive hold means the White House cannot simply bundle Ueland into a package of confirmations and move it through on a voice vote. If the committee advances him, the nomination would still need floor time in a lame-duck session crowded with spending bills and other confirmations, and the new Democratic majority takes over in January.

Advertisement

If Ueland is confirmed, he would hold the comptroller general's office for 15 years, a term that would span the rest of Trump's presidency and two administrations after it. The GAO's work on impoundment would continue under his leadership, and the 46 investigations already opened, with 12 findings of unlawful withholding, would be his to oversee. Ueland told the committee he took an affirmative decision not to review those findings before the hearing, saying it was critical that he not prejudge the agency's conclusions, and he promised that the GAO's process of reviewing claims about potential violations of law would continue to be a hallmark of his tenure. Whether Congress believes that promise will be decided in the committee vote, and then, if the nomination advances, on the Senate floor. Stay with TrendSignal for fresh US news every day.

Source: Government Executive

Advertisement
Advertisement

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Advertisement
Advertisement
About Us  |  Contact Us  |  Privacy Policy  |  Disclaimer  |  Terms and Conditions