Politics

Politics News: CBO Chief Retires, Democrats Choose Next

The head of Congress's nonpartisan budget scorekeeper is stepping down, and the decision about who replaces him will fall to the Democrats who swept both chambers of Congress in this month's midterm elections. Phillip Swagel, the director of the Congressional Budget Office since 2019, announced on Monday that he will leave the agency when his second four-year term ends on January 3, and return to teaching economics at the University of Maryland. His departure hands the incoming Democratic majority one of the most consequential personnel choices in Washington, because the person who leads the budget office shapes how every major bill is priced, and therefore what Congress can pass. In the latest politics news, the retirement sets up a contest over an institution that both parties have praised in public and pressured in private, and the choice of a successor will be one of the first tests of the new Congress.

Swagel announced his decision in a message posted on the budget office's website. "It has been a privilege to lead CBO since 2019," he wrote, adding that he and his colleagues had worked to provide lawmakers with objective and impartial budget and economic analysis, following the path set by the agency's founding director, Alice Rivlin. He thanked the chairs and ranking members of the House and Senate Budget Committees for their support and guidance, and credited the agency's staff with the work it produced. "When the COVID-19 pandemic upended all of our lives, the people at CBO took care of one another and kept serving Congress," he wrote. "It has been the honor of my professional life to work with them."

The timing matters as much as the content. Democrats won control of the House and the Senate in the midterm elections of November 3, and they will take charge of Congress in January, just as Swagel's term expires. That sequence means the new majority, rather than the outgoing Republican leadership, will have the decisive voice in choosing the next director. The Speaker of the House and the president pro tempore of the Senate jointly appoint the director, after considering recommendations from the chairs of the House and Senate Budget Committees. With Democrats about to hold those chairs, the two lawmakers expected to carry the most influence in the search are Representative Brendan Boyle of Pennsylvania, who is in line to lead the House Budget Committee, and Senator Tim Kaine of Virginia, who is expected to hold a central role on the Senate side.

Advertisement

Politics News: How the Next CBO Director Gets Chosen

The process for choosing a budget office director is written into the law that created the agency, and it is designed to keep the job above partisan politics. Under the Congressional Budget Act of 1974, the director serves a four-year term and is appointed jointly by the Speaker of the House and the president pro tempore of the Senate, after they consider the recommendations of the chairs of the two Budget Committees. The arrangement gives both chambers a voice, and it gives the Budget Committees, whose members work most closely with the agency, the first say in who should lead it. A director whose term expires can keep serving until a successor is chosen, so there is no hard deadline that would leave the agency leaderless if the search runs long. But the incoming Congress will be under pressure to move quickly, because the new director will need to be in place before the next round of major legislation reaches the floor.

The director is the most visible face of an agency that both parties rely on and both parties have, at various moments, accused of getting the numbers wrong. Swagel himself was a Republican administration veteran, having served as an assistant Treasury secretary under President George W. Bush, yet he won praise from Democrats during his tenure, and the Wall Street Journal noted that he had earned plaudits from the other side of the aisle even as his estimates frustrated Republican lawmakers. The search now under way will test whether that tradition of cross-party credibility can hold in a Congress that has just changed hands after a bruising election. What the new majority wants from the next director is no secret. Democrats will want a scorekeeper whose estimates they can trust when they write their own legislation, and whose independence they can defend when the White House or the other party challenges the numbers. They will also want someone who can stand up to pressure, because the budget office's most important work is telling Congress what its ideas actually cost, and that answer is often unwelcome.

The last director to leave the job before Swagel, Keith Hall, served from 2015 to 2019, and his predecessor, Douglas Elmendorf, served from 2009 to 2015, a period that included the scoring of the Affordable Care Act. Each of them learned that the job is less about economics than about credibility, and that credibility, once spent, is hard to recover. The calendar gives the incoming Congress a narrow window. Swagel's term ends on January 3, the new Congress is seated in the days around that date, and the search for a successor is expected to begin in earnest once the Budget Committee chairs are in place. Names will circulate in Washington in the coming weeks, and the choice will be read as a signal of how the new majority intends to govern. A pick drawn from academia, as Swagel was, would suggest continuity. A pick with a sharper partisan profile would suggest something else entirely, and would draw a fight.

Advertisement

Congress: What the CBO Does and Why the Job Matters

Congress created the office in the Congressional Budget Act of 1974 and established it the following year, to give lawmakers their own source of budget and economic analysis, independent of the president's Office of Management and Budget. Before the office existed, Congress had to rely on the White House's numbers when it debated spending and taxes. The budget office changed that balance, and it has been the legislature's scorekeeper ever since, producing the cost estimates for nearly every bill that moves through Capitol Hill and the economic forecasts that frame every budget debate.

The agency's best-known product is its annual report, The Budget and Economic Outlook, which projects what the federal budget and the economy would look like over the next decade if the laws governing taxes and spending generally remained unchanged. That projection, known as the baseline, is the starting point for every argument about deficits and debt, and it is the yardstick against which every proposal is measured. When a committee writes a bill, the budget office estimates what it would cost. When a party claims its plan would reduce the deficit, the budget office's estimate is the test of that claim. The office does not make policy recommendations, and it does not take sides in the debate over what Congress should do. Its authority comes from the perception, built over five decades, that its numbers are honest even when they are inconvenient.

That authority is why the director's job is so sensitive. The director sets the tone for the agency, defends its methods before Congress, and takes the heat when an estimate angers the party in power. The first director, Alice Rivlin, served from 1975 to 1983 and built the institution from nothing, establishing the practices and the reputation that her successors inherited. Swagel invoked her in his farewell message, a reminder that the job is as much about stewardship as it is about economics. The agency's staff of economists and analysts does the modelling, but the director is the one who stands behind it, and the one who absorbs the criticism when the modelling produces an answer that a president or a party does not want to hear.

Advertisement

The $4 Trillion Megabill and the Baseline Fight

No episode in Swagel's tenure tested that trust more than the domestic policy package Republicans enacted last year, the sprawling bill that combined tax cuts with spending changes and became the centrepiece of the party's legislative programme. The budget office estimated that the package would add more than four trillion dollars to the federal deficit over the coming decade, a figure that Republicans denounced and Democrats repeated at every opportunity. The dispute was not only about the size of the number. It was about the method used to produce it, and about whether the rules of budget scoring could be bent to make an expensive bill look cheap.

At the Republicans' request, Swagel's office also produced estimates using an alternative accounting approach, known as the current policy baseline, which treats tax provisions that are scheduled to expire as though they will continue, rather than assuming they lapse as the law says they will. Under that approach, the same bill appeared to cost far less, because the tax cuts it extended were no longer counted as new spending. The alternative estimates allowed Republican lawmakers to claim the legislation would cost far less than under the traditional method, and they helped the party sidestep procedural obstacles in the Senate, where the rules governing budget reconciliation can turn on a single estimate. Swagel's willingness to provide the alternative figures drew criticism from Democrats, who saw it as an accommodation of a party that wanted a friendlier number, and praise from Republicans, who saw it as a fair presentation of the choices involved.

The episode captured the dilemma of the job. The budget office is supposed to be neutral, but neutrality in a fight over accounting rules can look like taking sides, and every decision about method carries political consequences. Swagel maintained a productive relationship with Republican lawmakers through the dispute, and the reporting on his departure notes that he kept that relationship even as the party bristled at his headline estimate. That ability to disagree with the majority while keeping its confidence is one of the reasons his tenure lasted seven years, spanning two administrations and two changes of control in Congress. The same year also brought quieter work: Swagel helped Republican lawmakers in their search for ways to root out waste, fraud, and abuse in federal programmes, and his office worked with the Centres for Medicare and Medicaid Services to identify potential savings, including measures to prevent fraudulent payments for skin substitutes, the products used to treat wounds.

Advertisement

Swagel's Seven Years at the Helm

Swagel came to the budget office from academia, and he is returning there. He was a professor at the University of Maryland's School of Public Policy before his appointment, and he will resume teaching economics there when he leaves Washington. He became the tenth director of the agency on June 3, 2019, and he was reappointed to a second four-year term on July 27, 2023, by the House and Senate leadership of the time. The reappointment was a vote of confidence from both parties, and it meant that his tenure would stretch across the end of one presidency, the whole of the next, and the beginning of another, a span that included a pandemic, a war in Europe, and the most expensive domestic legislation in a generation.

His background before the budget office was in both government and the university. From 2006 to 2009, he was the assistant secretary for economic policy at the Treasury Department, where he worked on the response to the financial crisis and on the Troubled Asset Relief Program, the bank rescue that became one of the most controversial policies of its era. He had earlier served as chief of staff and senior economist at the White House Council of Economic Advisers, and as an economist at the Federal Reserve Board and the International Monetary Fund. He taught at Northwestern University, the University of Chicago's Booth School of Business, and Georgetown University, and he was a visiting scholar at the American Enterprise Institute and the Milken Institute. He earned his bachelor's degree in economics from Princeton University and his doctorate from Harvard University, and his research has covered financial market reform, international trade policy, and China's role in the global economy.

Those credentials made him an unusual figure in Washington: an economist who had worked in crisis management, in the White House, and in the classroom, and who arrived at the budget office with a reputation in all three worlds. The small details of his tenure suggest why the staff he led took pride in the work. His office at the budget office features a stuffed skunk, a gift from staff that plays on a long-running joke about the agency's role as the voice of fiscal reality in a city that prefers good news. The joke is that the budget office is the skunk at the garden party, the institution that arrives with an unwelcome number. Swagel seemed to enjoy the joke, and to understand the job it described.

Advertisement

Democratic Party News: What Democrats Want in a Successor

The choice Democrats now face is not only about a person. It is about what the budget office will be for the next four years, and whose numbers will shape the laws the new Congress writes. The incoming majority arrives with an ambitious agenda, and every item on it will need a cost estimate before it can move. Tax policy, health care, and the spending bills that keep the government open will all pass through the agency's analysts, and the director will be the one who presents the results to the committees and to the public. A director the new majority trusts will make that process smoother. A director it does not trust will make every bill a fight about the numbers before it can become a fight about the policy.

The fiscal landscape the next director will inherit is unforgiving. The federal debt has grown through years of deficits, interest payments on that debt consume a rising share of the budget, and the tax provisions extended in last year's megabill will come up for debate again. The debt ceiling, the statutory limit on federal borrowing, will return as a point of confrontation, as it has in nearly every recent Congress, and the budget office's estimates of when the government will run out of room to borrow are the figures both parties use to set the deadline. In that environment, the director's credibility is not an abstraction. It is the difference between a negotiation that both sides accept and a standoff in which neither side believes the numbers. Democrats will also be watching for a subtler quality: the willingness to say no to the majority that appointed them. The budget office's authority depends on its independence from the party that chose its director, and the strongest directors have been the ones who disappointed their own side. Swagel disappointed Republicans with his estimate of their signature bill, and he kept their confidence anyway. Boyle and Kaine will be looking for a successor who can do the same for the new majority.

US Politics: What Happens Next

The immediate future is a timetable. Swagel's term ends on January 3, and he will remain in the job until a successor is appointed if the search is not finished by then, as the law allows. The new Congress will be seated in early January, the Budget Committees will organise, and the recommendations for the next director will go to the Speaker and the president pro tempore. The names under consideration are not yet public, and the process is expected to play out over the coming weeks, with the new chairs consulting former directors, economists, and the agency's own staff.

Advertisement

Swagel, for his part, will return to the University of Maryland, where he holds a position as a professor of international economic policy at the School of Public Policy. The move closes a circle that began when he left the university for Washington in 2019, and it returns one of the capital's most experienced fiscal voices to the classroom. The agency he leaves behind is larger and more visible than the one he found, and its next director will inherit both its reputation and its burdens. The choice matters beyond Washington because the budget office's numbers shape the arguments every American hears about what government can afford. When the next Congress debates tax cuts or health care or the debt ceiling, the first question will be what it costs, and the answer will come from the agency Swagel is leaving. Democrats have won the right to choose who gives that answer, and the rest of Washington will be watching who they pick.

Source: The Washington Post

Advertisement
Advertisement

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Advertisement
Advertisement
About Us  |  Contact Us  |  Privacy Policy  |  Disclaimer  |  Terms and Conditions