Iran War News: Senate Rejects Bid to Curb Trump Strikes
In the latest iran war news, the United States Senate has rejected a resolution that would have directed President Donald Trump to remove American forces from hostilities with Iran, voting 51 to 48 on Thursday in the first test of Republican support for the war since the midterm elections stripped the party of its control of Congress. The vote was the first time either chamber of Congress had taken up the Iran war since voters went to the polls on November 3, and it arrived just weeks after an election in which the conflict weighed heavily on the outcome. Three Republicans broke with their party to support the measure, while one Democrat voted against it, and the narrow margin left the resolution short of the majority it needed even as Democrats promised that the fight is far from over.
The measure, House Concurrent Resolution 93, had already passed the House of Representatives in September by a vote of 220 to 204, with the support of seven Republicans. It would have directed the president to remove United States armed forces from hostilities against Iran unless Congress explicitly authorized those operations through a declaration of war or a specific authorization for the use of military force. The Senate's rejection means the measure will not be adopted, and the congressional direction it contained will not take effect. The Senate's official floor account recorded the result at 2:42 p.m. Eastern time on Thursday afternoon.
The vote was never expected to end the war on its own. As a concurrent resolution, it would not have gone to the president's desk for his signature, and even if it had passed, its practical effect would have been largely symbolic. The White House ignored a similar resolution that Congress passed in June, and administrations of both parties have long argued that the procedure Congress used to force the vote is unconstitutional. But the vote mattered for a different reason: it forced every senator to take a public position on a war that voters had just punished the governing party for.
Iran War News: How the Senate Vote Broke Down
The vote broke largely along party lines, with the exceptions telling the story of a war that has divided both parties in different ways. Three Republicans voted in favor of the resolution: Senator Susan Collins of Maine, Senator Lisa Murkowski of Alaska, and Senator Rand Paul of Kentucky. All three have been among the most independent voices in the Republican conference on questions of war powers, and all three have supported efforts to restrain presidential war-making before. Their votes gave the resolution 48 supporters, three short of the 51 it needed to pass.
One Democrat voted against the measure: Senator John Fetterman of Pennsylvania, who has broken with his party on the conflict before and has been one of the war's most consistent supporters among Democrats. Senator Chris Murphy of Connecticut, who is recovering from a stroke he suffered last month, missed the vote. Two departing Republican senators who have at times backed similar measures, Senator Thom Tillis of North Carolina and Senator Bill Cassidy of Louisiana, voted against the resolution this time, a sign of how the politics of the war have hardened even among Republicans who once supported congressional restraint.
The debate on the Senate floor before the vote captured the two arguments that have defined the war since it began. Senator Tim Sheehy, a Republican from Montana, spoke against the resolution, arguing that the United States could not ignore the threat posed by Iran. "Iran is not a war of choice," Sheehy said on the Senate floor. "It's a war of necessity." The argument, made by the administration and its supporters throughout the conflict, is that the campaign against Iran is a defensive necessity rather than a discretionary war, and that Congress should not tie the president's hands while American forces are engaged.
Senator Tim Kaine of Virginia, the Democrat who has orchestrated his party's campaign to force war powers votes, made the opposite case. Kaine, who has called repeatedly for Congress to take back its control over declarations of war, said the midterm election result reflected Americans' unhappiness about the war, and about the higher prices for food, fuel, and other goods linked to the conflict. "Its unpopularity was made absolutely, manifestly clear in the election results of November 3," Kaine said in a speech before the vote, appealing for yes votes. Senator Tammy Baldwin, a Democrat from Wisconsin, made the same argument in blunter terms. "While I am confident that the next Democratic Congress will listen to the American people and end this war, time is of the essence," Baldwin said on the Senate floor before the vote. "We can and must take the message voters sent us and act now to end this war."
The War Powers Resolution and the Constitutional Fight
The legal framework behind Thursday's vote is the War Powers Resolution of 1973, a federal law enacted in the aftermath of the Vietnam War that was designed to restrain presidents from waging war without Congress. The law states that the president must remove United States forces engaged in hostilities abroad without congressional authorization if Congress passes such a resolution. It was the mechanism Democrats used to force the vote, and it is the mechanism they have used repeatedly in their campaign against the Iran war. The resolution at issue invoked section 5(c) of the law, which provides for Congress to direct a withdrawal through a concurrent resolution, a measure that does not require the president's signature.
The constitutional fight over that mechanism is as old as the law itself. The White House and Republicans contend that the Supreme Court has held such resolutions unconstitutional, pointing to the court's 1983 ruling in Immigration and Naturalization Service v. Chadha, which held that Congress could not restrain the president's veto power in the way the War Powers Resolution attempts to do. The Trump administration has said that it believes the provision allowing Congress to pass a war powers resolution that cannot be vetoed is especially objectionable, and it has acted accordingly: when Congress passed a similar resolution in June, the White House simply ignored it.
Democrats have argued that the courts have never considered whether the Chadha precedent applies to war powers resolutions, and that the question has never been tested in the context of an actual war. They also argue that the conflict itself is unlawful because Congress never voted to authorize it, a point that goes to the heart of the constitutional division of war powers. The Constitution reserves the power to declare war to Congress, and President Trump never asked Congress to authorize military action against Iran. The president also disregarded a 60-day legal deadline to remove United States forces from hostilities, arguing that the deadline did not apply because hostilities were over, an argument his critics reject.
Senator Josh Hawley, a Republican from Missouri, illustrated the complexity of the politics in his own explanation of his vote. Hawley said he opposed the resolution because he accepts the administration's argument that there are no current hostilities, but he added that he would not vote to authorize the war and would almost certainly oppose funding it. "Speaking just for my state, I think that voters want this drawing to a close, and I think they're right about that," Hawley told reporters after the vote.
Midterm Elections 2026: The War on the Ballot
Thursday's vote was the first time the Senate had considered a major Iran war-related measure since the Democratic victories in the midterm elections on November 3, and the election hung over every speech on the floor. The United States-Israel war on Iran, which started on February 28, has become the defining issue of the second Trump administration's foreign policy, and voters made their judgment on it clear. Republicans suffered sweeping defeats, losing control of Congress, and many in the party, including Vice President JD Vance, have blamed the wipeout on the war's unpopularity.
What Happens Next: The Funding Deadline and a New Congress
The exit polling tells the story in numbers. In Iowa, where Democrats flipped a Republican-held Senate seat, 61 percent of voters said taking military action against Iran was the wrong decision, while 39 percent called it the right decision. A majority of voters also said military action was the wrong decision in eight other states Democrats flipped: Maine, Mississippi, South Carolina, North Carolina, Texas, Ohio, Kansas, and Alaska.
The defeat of the resolution does not settle the wider dispute over the war, and both sides made clear on Thursday that the fight will move to new ground. The next test is the government funding deadline. The federal government is set to shut down on December 12 unless Congress approves more funding, and Democrats have pledged to end the war but are still debating their strategy. Some Senate Democrats have called for refusing to pass a government funding bill next month if it includes money for the war, a threat that would turn the funding fight into a proxy battle over the conflict itself.
The funding question is where the war's opponents may have their strongest leverage. A war powers resolution can be ignored, as the White House demonstrated in June, but a funding bill cannot be passed without votes, and the December 11 deadline for full funding gives Democrats a concrete moment to force a choice. Senator Hawley's warning that he would almost certainly oppose funding the war suggests the funding fight could divide Republicans as well as Democrats.
The longer-term picture is clearer. Democrats will have the votes to pass similar resolutions in January once they control Congress, and Senator Kaine said after the vote that his party would keep pushing to end the war. "President Trump should do what is right for Americans and end the war now," Kaine said in a statement after the vote. "If he doesn't, my colleagues and I in the new Democratic majority Congress will be exploring every possible additional tool to force an end to the war."
For now, the war continues, the blockade remains in place, and the question of whether the United States will resume strikes is unresolved. Thursday's vote answered one question, whether the current Senate would direct the president to withdraw, and left the larger questions to a new Congress and a funding deadline. The 51 to 48 margin, narrow as it was, was enough to defeat the resolution. Whether it will be enough to sustain the war through the fights ahead is a different question, and the answer will come in December and January.
Source: The Washington Post