Politics

Immigration News: Miller Role Dims Deal Hopes

The immigration news from Washington this week has been dominated by a single personnel decision and the question it raises for the next Congress: can there be any bipartisan deal on immigration when the man Democrats regard as the architect of the administration's crackdown is now the president's chief of staff? Stephen Miller's promotion to the most powerful staff job in the White House has hardened Democratic doubts that compromise is possible once their party takes control of Congress in January, and it has opened a split inside the Republican Party over whether the move helps or hurts the chances of legislation. Yet at least one Republican in a competitive district argues the opposite — that Miller's standing with the president's base makes him the one figure who could carry hardliners into a deal, if President Donald Trump decides he wants one.

The appointment that changed the calculation

President Trump announced on November 6 that Miller, then his deputy chief of staff for policy and homeland security adviser, would become his new chief of staff. The promotion came three days after the midterm elections of November 3, in which Democrats won control of both chambers of Congress, and it placed the administration's most prominent immigration hardliner at the centre of every decision the White House will make in the final two years of the president's term. Miller, 41, has spent his career arguing for sharply lower immigration and tougher enforcement, beginning as a policy aide to then-Senator Jeff Sessions of Alabama and later driving the first Trump administration's travel ban and family separation policy, and he is widely credited — and blamed — with designing the enforcement campaign that has defined the second Trump administration.

His record helps explain why Democrats reacted so strongly. As the administration's policy chief on immigration, Miller set a target of 3,000 immigration arrests a day and stayed in close contact with the enforcement operation as it carried out street-level sweeps in Los Angeles, Chicago and Minneapolis. The campaign dramatically slowed illegal crossings at the southern border, a result the White House presents as its signature achievement. It also produced mass arrests and deportations that exit polling found deeply unpopular: nearly six in ten voters told exit pollsters that the administration's immigration enforcement had gone too far. Some Republican lawmakers have blamed Miller for turning what had been one of the party's strongest issues into a liability, arguing that the scale and visibility of the enforcement drive contributed to the party's losses in the midterms.

Advertisement

LaLota's case: the enforcer as dealmaker

Against that backdrop, the most surprising voice in the debate belongs to Representative Nick LaLota, a Republican from New York who narrowly won re-election in one of the country's most competitive districts. LaLota told The Washington Sun that Miller's hardline reputation could actually help persuade reluctant House members to support a deal, because the chief of staff carries credibility with the president's base that no moderate could match. In his telling, the obstacle to an immigration compromise has never been the policy details alone; it has been the fear among Republicans that any deal would be denounced as a betrayal by the party's right flank. A chief of staff who cannot plausibly be accused of going soft, LaLota argued, could give those members cover to vote yes.

"I think there is a negotiation to be had, not just with Democrats, of bringing Republicans online," LaLota said. "Stephen Miller could have a large hand on bringing those sorts of Republicans on board with some sort of compromise effort." His argument rests on the president's own recent comments. In an interview with "60 Minutes" on CBS that aired on November 8, Trump said his deportations "might be too tough" and suggested he could reach a deal with Democrats for immigrants who had lived in the country for years. LaLota pointed to those remarks as evidence that the president is serious about pursuing an immigration deal, and he suggested that Miller's influence with the president and with congressional hardliners could prove useful in trying to strike one.

LaLota also sketched what a deal might look like from the Republican side. He said Congress has an opportunity to write some of Trump's border-security initiatives into law so they survive future administrations, while taking a "different approach" to deportations by prioritising people convicted of violent crimes and those he described as illegally relying on public benefits. The framing matters: it would let Republicans claim they had locked in the border gains while softening the enforcement that voters have turned against, and it would give Democrats a measure of protection for long-settled residents. Ultimately, LaLota argued, Miller answers to the president, and the president decides. "The decision-making starts at the president, and then he surrounds himself with staff members who can execute on his decision-making," he said.

Advertisement

Democrats: no trust, no mediator

For Democrats, the appointment has had the opposite effect: it has convinced them that the White House is not interested in compromise at all. Representative Hakeem Jeffries, the Democrat expected to become the next speaker of the House, has been blunt. "I've been very clear about Stephen Miller. His appointment was dangerous and reckless and irresponsible, in my view," Jeffries said, and he has separately described Miller as "a stone-cold racist." Given the hostility between the two men, it is unclear who could serve as a mediator between the incoming Democratic leadership and the president's right-hand man.

Representative Nanette Barragan of California, who has been on the front lines of Democratic efforts to shape immigration policy, was sceptical that Miller would be willing to engage, though she stopped short of closing the door on future talks. She said the appointment did not signal an opening on immigration, because Miller could not be trusted, but added that she was willing to set her scepticism aside if the administration delivered results. It was a carefully conditional position: open to a deal in principle, doubtful in practice, and demanding proof before trust.

Other Democrats were less equivocal. Representative Gregory Meeks of New York, who is expected to chair the House Foreign Affairs Committee, said he was surprised that Miller was given the promotion and questioned whether his rhetoric made him a viable negotiating partner. "The devil is always in the details," Meeks said. "But what we can only go by is what our eyes have seen and our ears have heard." Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez questioned whether Miller would even remain in the job, noting the administration's history of turnover, but described his influence as a potentially dangerous development, saying she did not see how he could sustain the amount of decision-making now resting with him and expressing hope that the president would find someone better suited to the post.

Advertisement

The 60 Minutes whiplash: from doable to no amnesty

The reason anyone is still talking about a deal at all is the extraordinary 48 hours that followed Miller's promotion. On November 8, in the "60 Minutes" interview, Trump gave himself high marks for closing the border and then, unprompted, opened the door to a compromise. He said his deportations "might be too tough" and suggested he could reach a deal with Democrats for immigrants who had lived in the country for years. For nearly a day, bipartisan immigration reform — dormant for years — was suddenly back in the conversation. Democrats seized on the opening, and the administration's homeland security chief, Markwayne Mullin, had already floated a green-card path for DACA recipients, the young immigrants brought to the country as children.

Then, on November 9, the window slammed shut. Following a torrent of criticism from conservative influencers, the House Freedom Caucus and the Heritage Foundation, Trump told reporters there would be no amnesty and that his policy had not changed. The sequence — an appointment that put the enforcement campaign's architect in the chief of staff's chair, a hint of flexibility, a backlash from the base, and a firm reversal — is the clearest illustration yet of the forces pulling the president in opposite directions, and of why Democrats doubt that any opening will survive contact with the politics of his own party.

2018: the last time a deal collapsed

There is a precedent for this moment, and it does not encourage optimism. In 2018, the last time Trump appeared ready to strike an immigration deal with Democrats, the talks collapsed after a White House meeting that lawmakers in both parties blamed on Miller. The details of that meeting have been disputed ever since, but the outcome is not: a compromise that had seemed within reach fell apart, and immigration reform went back into the deep freeze for another eight years. Now Miller is not merely in the room — he decides who gets in the room. That is the fact Democrats keep returning to, and it is the reason so many of them treat the current talk of a deal as a mirage.

Advertisement

What happens next in a divided Washington

The immediate question is what, if anything, can happen before the new Congress takes its seats in January. Representative Warren Davidson, a Republican from Ohio, suggested Miller's appointment could have consequences for the White House's relationship with the legislative branch, although he expects little immediate impact during the lame-duck session. "It might have an impact on the next Congress. Like, who's going to work well with the next Congress, but I don't think it's going to have any impact on the lame duck," Davidson said. His assessment reflects the reality that the outgoing Republican majority has only weeks left and little appetite for a fight over immigration in its final days.

The longer question is what the next two years will look like. With Democrats in control of both chambers, the White House will need Democratic votes for any legislation, including on immigration. The administration's stated position, as spokeswoman Taylor Rogers put it, is that the president's strong immigration policy remains unchanged, and that Democrats should work with the administration to keep the southern border secure, remove dangerous criminals from communities, and stop the trafficking of lethal drugs. That is a demand for cooperation on the administration's terms, not an offer of compromise. Rogers also argued that Miller had already shepherded bipartisan proposals, pointing to public safety reform, efforts to make cities such as Washington, D.C. and Memphis safer, drug pricing transparency, and what she called a nuclear energy renaissance.

The House Freedom Caucus, meanwhile, has made its own position clear. Its chair, Representative Andy Harris of Maryland, said in a statement about the possibility of an immigration deal: "No amnesty. No compromises. Full stop." The most likely outcome, for now, is stalemate punctuated by investigation. Democrats have promised subpoenas and hearings into the enforcement campaign, and the White House has promised to defend it. The one scenario in which a deal becomes possible is the one LaLota described: the president deciding he wants a legacy achievement on immigration and using Miller's credibility with the base to bring hardliners along. It is a narrow path, and it depends on a president who has just spent 48 hours demonstrating how quickly he can reverse himself under pressure from his own supporters. But it is the only path anyone has identified, and it is the reason the conversation has not died entirely.

Advertisement

Source: The Washington Post

Advertisement

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Advertisement
Advertisement
About Us  |  Contact Us  |  Privacy Policy  |  Disclaimer  |  Terms and Conditions