Democratic Party News: Van Hollen Ramps Up Schumer Challenge
The democratic party news out of Washington this weekend is no longer about a single announcement. Two days after Senator Chris Van Hollen of Maryland declared his challenge to Senator Chuck Schumer of New York for the leadership of the Senate Democrats, the contest has become a full public campaign, with a closed door on a presidential run, new endorsements and the backing of major labor unions. Van Hollen, 67, is running to lead a caucus that will hold at least 55 seats in the new Congress, and he is framing the race as a choice between the party’s past and its future. Schumer, 75, who has led Senate Democrats since 2017, says he has the votes to stay. The two men will learn who is right on December 1, when Senate Democrats vote by secret ballot for their next leader.
The speed of the campaign is the story. Van Hollen announced his bid on Thursday night, November 12, in an interview with MS NOW host Jen Psaki, nine days after the 2026 midterms handed Democrats control of both chambers of Congress. By Friday afternoon he was in Denver, telling reporters at the “What’s Next” conference that he was abandoning the presidential ambitions he had been openly weighing. His campaign has since launched a website.
Democratic party news: Van Hollen closes the door on 2028
The decision to rule out a 2028 presidential run matters because it removes the question that had hung over Van Hollen for months. In June he had said he was “kicking the tires” on a White House bid after visiting New Hampshire, and the day after the midterm elections he told the Wall Street Journal he was still interested in a presidential run in 2028. As recently as the Saturday before his announcement, he told CNN that seeking the leadership job was “not my focus.” On Friday in Denver, all of that ended in a single sentence. Asked whether entering the race for Senate majority leader closed the door on a potential 2028 campaign, Van Hollen replied: “I’m no longer pursuing that.” He also ruled out reconsidering a White House run if he loses the leadership race.
The venue mattered, too. The “What’s Next” conference in Denver, hosted by the moderate group Majority Democrats, gathered Democratic leaders, strategists and activists to debate the party’s direction after the midterms, and Van Hollen used it to make his case in person to the party’s professional class. Democrats flipped eight Senate seats on November 3 and will hold at least 55 seats in January, with a 56th possible if Mary Peltola wins the still-uncalled Alaska race against Republican incumbent Dan Sullivan. “This is not about any one individual, but it is about answering the call of the American people,” Van Hollen said when he announced his candidacy, adding that voters had called on Democrats to reject the status quo. By closing the door on 2028, he has bet his political future on this contest, with no fallback to a presidential campaign if he loses.
The endorsement race: Schumer leads in public, Van Hollen claims more in private
The public count, as of Friday, favors Schumer by a wide margin. Axios counted 14 senators publicly backing Schumer, including Schumer himself, against five for Van Hollen, and a separate tally by the Washington Examiner put the margin at 15 against four. Schumer’s public backers include Senators Kirsten Gillibrand of New York, Ruben Gallego of Arizona, John Fetterman of Pennsylvania, Mark Kelly of Arizona, Brian Schatz of Hawaii, Tammy Baldwin of Wisconsin and Senator-elect Sherrod Brown of Ohio. Allies of Schumer have predicted in private that he will win more than 40 votes when the caucus meets, and Schumer himself has said publicly that he has the votes to continue as leader.
Van Hollen’s public support is smaller but growing. Senator Bernie Sanders of Vermont backed him on Thursday night, and Senator Jeff Merkley of Oregon has since joined him. Two incoming senators have also declared for Van Hollen: Abdul El-Sayed of Michigan, who endorsed him immediately after the announcement, and Peggy Flanagan of Minnesota, who added her support on Friday morning. The gap between the public counts and Van Hollen’s own claims is where the race will be decided: he has told interviewers he has the support of “more than 10” senators, and he has described himself as the underdog while insisting the race “is very much in flux.” Several returning Senate Democrats, and most incoming freshmen, have declined to publicly back Schumer, according to CNN’s reporting. Senator Elissa Slotkin of Michigan has said she will not vote for Schumer, though she has not endorsed Van Hollen. With 55 seats in the incoming caucus and only 19 senators publicly declared for either man, dozens have yet to say which candidate they will support, and the winner will need 28 votes, or 29 if Democrats reach 56 seats with a win in Alaska.
Labor lines up behind the challenger
If the endorsement race among senators favors Schumer, the race among organized labor has moved sharply the other way, and that matters because Van Hollen’s campaign is built on a working-class message. The International Association of Machinists and Aerospace Workers, a union representing about 600,000 members, called on Schumer not to seek the leadership post on November 10, and on November 12 it formally endorsed Van Hollen. Its president, Brian Bryant, called Van Hollen “a proven champion of working people who will fight to unrig an economy stacked against working families.”
A second union followed on Friday. The Office and Professional Employees International Union, representing 90,000 office and professional workers, wrote to Schumer asking him to decline to seek the majority leader’s post, and backed Van Hollen for the job instead. The Working Families Party, influential in the politics of Schumer’s home state of New York, has also urged Schumer not to seek another term as leader, and the climate group Sunrise Movement has called for Schumer to step aside in favor of Van Hollen. None of these groups votes on December 1, but together they frame the race for the senators who do.
What Van Hollen would do differently
The clearest policy difference between the two men is the filibuster, and Van Hollen has made it the centerpiece of his pitch. He has said he would move to end the filibuster if elected leader, so that a majority of 51 senators could pass legislation rather than needing 60 votes to break a minority blockade. Schumer has never supported ending the filibuster, and the contrast gives senators a concrete choice: a leader who would use the majority’s full power, or one who would work within the Senate’s traditional constraints. For a caucus that will hold its largest majority in years, the question of whether to use that majority is the most consequential decision the next leader will face.
Van Hollen has also promised a harder line against the Trump administration. He has said he would use the “full power” of the Senate to press for an end to the war in Iran and to lower the cost of living, and he has floated using the December 11 deadline, when federal spending authority expires, to withhold money for the Iran war even if that means a government shutdown. His record gives the pitch credibility with the senators he is courting: he has broken with Schumer on major votes, including backing resolutions to block some weapons sales to Israel while Schumer voted against them, and he drew national attention when he traveled to El Salvador to press the case of Kilmar Abrego Garcia, a Maryland resident the administration had deported.
Why Schumer’s critics say the moment has come
Schumer’s critics have been building their case for years, and the midterm victory gave them their opening. The New York senator has led Senate Democrats since 2017, through periods in the majority and in the minority, and for most of that time his position went unchallenged. The turning point for many of his critics came in March 2025, when Schumer helped advance a Republican-backed government funding bill, a decision that infuriated progressives who wanted the party to use its leverage in a funding fight. That vote has fueled much of the backlash from the left ever since, and it is the single event Van Hollen’s supporters cite most often when they explain why a change is needed. The argument is not that Schumer failed to win elections, but that his pragmatic, deal-oriented style is a poor fit for a moment when the party’s voters want confrontation with the Trump administration.
The contest is also the first of its kind in a generation. There has not been a contested election for Senate Democratic leader since 1994, and Van Hollen argues a party that has not debated its Senate leadership in 32 years is overdue for the argument. Schumer’s response has been to welcome the discussion while insisting he will win it. “I welcome any discussion about the future of our caucus and the important work ahead,” he said in a statement after Van Hollen’s announcement, adding that he was proud of what the party had accomplished together and that he had “the votes to continue serving as Democratic Leader.”
What happens next
The formal timetable is short. Senate Democrats will choose their leader by secret ballot on December 1, and there has been discussion among Democrats about moving the vote up to next week to cut short a drawn-out fight, though no decision has been announced. The winner will need a simple majority of the caucus, 28 votes if the caucus holds 55 seats, or 29 if the Alaska race breaks for Peltola and the caucus grows to 56. Incoming senators will take part in the vote, which gives the freshmen who have been most sympathetic to Van Hollen a direct say in the outcome.
The stakes reach beyond the Senate chamber. Whoever wins on December 1 will set the Democratic agenda in the Senate for the final two years of President Donald Trump’s second term, deciding how aggressively the new majority investigates the administration, how it uses the filibuster, and how it spends the political capital of a midterm victory. If he wins, the Senate’s top Democrat will be a man who has staked everything on the job; if he loses, the party will have had its first open debate about its Senate leadership in 32 years and chosen continuity anyway. The next two weeks will decide whether the party changes its leadership as well.
Source: The Washington Post