MAGA Movement: Oath Keepers Founder ‘Done’ With Trump
In a striking break inside the maga movement, Stewart Rhodes, the founder of the Oath Keepers militia and one of the most prominent figures convicted over the January 6 attack on the US Capitol, says he is finished with President Donald Trump. "I am absolutely done with Trump," Rhodes told The Associated Press in an interview in Irving, Texas, adding that he now considers the president not just a traitor, but "one of the very worst in our nation's history."
The repudiation is remarkable because of who is making it. Rhodes did not merely support Trump from a distance: he was convicted of seditious conspiracy for orchestrating an attempt to keep Trump in power after the 2020 election, and while serving his sentence he had a tattoo inked of Trump's defiant face after the president survived an assassin's bullet in Butler, Pennsylvania. That devotion, he now says, is over.
The interview, conducted at a rickety yellow table outside a gastropub in Irving, is the fullest account yet of how one of Trump's most committed former allies came to turn against him.
The Tattoo That Told the Story
The tattoo is where Rhodes's story begins and where it now ends. He was behind bars when Trump was fired on in Butler in July 2024, and he watched the assassination attempt on a prison television with other inmates. He saw Trump pump his fist and yell "fight," and he figured, as he put it, that God's hand was on the man. While still serving time for his role in the January 6 attack, he got a tattoo of Trump's defiant face, a permanent record of his loyalty to the president he believed had been chosen for the moment.
That loyalty has now curdled into something close to its opposite. Rhodes says he plans to have the prison tattoo changed to reflect what he now believes about the man it depicts. "I will have this prison tattoo of Trump 'modified,'" he wrote in a text message to the AP, "to reflect that reality. That treason." He did not specify what the modification would look like, only that the image of a leader he once revered will be altered to mark a leader he now calls a traitor.
The symbolism is hard to miss: a man in federal prison, serving an 18-year sentence, carrying the president's face on his skin, now planning to erase it. Rhodes sat shaded by a black cowboy hat as he explained how the man he once tattooed onto his body had become, in his words, one of the worst figures in the nation's history.
MAGA Movement: How the Break Happened
Rhodes traces the beginning of the split to the first days of Trump's second term, when the president pardoned hundreds of people locked up for their actions on January 6, 2021, but only commuted Rhodes's sentence. A pardon wipes the record clean; a commutation merely shortens the punishment. Rhodes got the lesser mercy, and he has not forgotten it. "That was the first inkling," he said. "He let us out of prison. We were grateful. I didn't get a pardon though."
The grievances piled up from there. Rhodes said Trump's war with Iran violated the president's promises to end foreign conflicts, a pledge that had been central to his appeal to supporters who opposed new wars abroad. He said it felt like an affront when Trump dismissed people who urged his administration to release files about the Jeffrey Epstein case, calling them "PAST supporters," as if their loyalty had expired. And he said Trump went back on the longtime slogan that had defined his movement.
"We elected him to end the corruption in Washington, D.C. 'Drain the swamp.' Unfortunately his administration has been one of the most corrupt administrations in U.S. history," Rhodes said. "The pardons are pay-for-play and everything is pay-for-play." The charge is a sweeping one, and Rhodes offered no evidence for it in the interview, but as a statement of how a former true believer now sees the administration, it could hardly be blunter.
Rhodes also ties his break to the midterm elections of November 3, in which Democrats scored historic victories in Texas and elsewhere, and he blames Trump directly for the losses. "The lion's share is because Trump pissed off his own base," he said. His argument is that the president took the loyalty of his most committed supporters for granted, and that the base responded by staying home. "The Republican Party has taken us for granted," he said, adding that he did not want to choose between "a half a dose of poison or a full dose." He did not register to vote in time for the election, and he said he would not have cast a ballot anyway.
Who Is Stewart Rhodes?
To understand why the break matters, it helps to know who Rhodes is. He graduated from Yale Law School and worked as a staffer for former US Representative Ron Paul of Texas before founding the Oath Keepers in 2009, with the goal of encouraging members of the military and law enforcement to resist what the group views as unconstitutional orders, such as disarming citizens or carrying out warrantless searches. The organization grew into one of the best-known far-right militia groups in the country, and it later allied itself closely with Trump's political movement.
Prosecutors said group members gathered weapons, organized trainings, and assembled in Washington, where some helped storm the Capitol on January 6, 2021. Rhodes himself did not enter the building that day, but prosecutors argued that he was the one giving the orders and directing the operation. A Washington jury convicted him of seditious conspiracy in November 2022, in a historic trial that tested the Justice Department's ability to hold January 6 defendants accountable. He was also found guilty of obstructing an official proceeding and tampering with documents.
In May 2023, US District Judge Amit Mehta sentenced Rhodes to 18 years in prison, one of the longest sentences handed down in any January 6 case. "You are smart, you are charismatic and compelling and frankly that's what makes you dangerous," Mehta said during the hearing. "The moment you are released, whenever that may be, you will be ready to take up arms against your government." Mehta had previously ruled that Rhodes's actions amounted to domestic terrorism. Rhodes, who called himself a "political prisoner," showed no remorse.
From Pardon Day to a Vacated Conviction
After Trump won the 2024 election, he moved swiftly to pardon hundreds of people convicted of crimes related to January 6, including those who assaulted police officers. Rhodes received a commutation instead, which freed him from prison but left his conviction on the record. He was released from federal prison on January 21, 2025, the day after the commutation took effect, and he has been pressing ever since for the full pardon he believes he was owed.
That campaign took a new turn earlier this year, when the Justice Department vacated Rhodes's conviction, lifting his felon status and restoring rights he had lost. With his rights restored, Rhodes said he is now working to rebuild the Oath Keepers, which previously had tens of thousands of members, according to leaked membership lists. The rebuilding effort is underway even as he declares himself finished with the president who freed him.
The March prelude to the break came earlier this year, when Rhodes guest-hosted the show of conspiracy theorist Alex Jones and announced that he no longer called himself MAGA. He said he was an "America-only patriot" and a "Christian nationalist," and he blamed the influence of foreign interests in the government for his decision. He was headed to Mar-a-Lago at the time to ask Trump for a pardon in person, and he said plainly that he would speak out even if it cost him the pardon. "If I lose my pardon because of that, then so be it," he said. The pardon never came, and the break he announced that day has now hardened into the full repudiation he delivered in Irving.
The 'Christ Is King' Conference and the Rebuild
The AP interview took place during a three-day conference in Irving called "Christ is King: America After Trump," a title that captures the direction Rhodes and his allies are now heading. Nearby, people mingled for his Christian Warriors After-Party, and some approached to sign up for the Oath Keepers or for trainings in community defense and hurricane relief.
The conference's framing connects Rhodes's break to a larger current inside the American right. Christian nationalists, who argue that the United States should be governed as an explicitly Christian nation, have been among the most organized voices looking past Trump, and they see the midterm losses as an opening to supplant his version of the movement. Rhodes, who now describes himself as a Christian nationalist, fits squarely in that current.
Sam Jackson, an associate professor at the University at Albany who studies anti-government extremism, told the AP that Rhodes is not alone in his about-face, and that there is an ideological through line to it. "They went from seeing Donald Trump as their ally in this fight against the conspiracy, to actually being co-opted by the conspiracy," Jackson said, adding that the shift "points to deeper consistency in that understanding of the world as driven by hidden, evil actors."
What Rhodes' Break Means for the MAGA Movement
The White House did not respond to a request for comment on Rhodes's remarks. That silence is itself notable, given how much of Trump's political identity has been built on the loyalty of supporters like Rhodes, the people who showed up, organized, and in his case went to prison. When a figure like Rhodes says the president took his base for granted, it is not a criticism from the opposition. It is a criticism from inside the house.
The practical question is how much it matters. Rhodes is one man, and the Oath Keepers, for all their notoriety, are a shadow of the organization they were before January 6, when leaked lists showed tens of thousands of members. But the pattern he represents is larger than he is: the fading of allegiance even among extreme supporters, and the willingness of figures once defined by their loyalty to the president to define themselves against him instead. The midterm results in Texas, where Democrats made historic gains, gave that pattern an electoral shape.
What to watch now is whether Rhodes's rebuild of the Oath Keepers gains traction, whether his tattoo modification becomes a public symbol of the break, and whether other prominent January 6 figures follow him in turning on the president who freed them. The pardon question also remains open: Rhodes still wants a full pardon, and he has now made clear he will not trade his criticism for it.
Source: Associated Press