College Football Playoff Race Shaken by Week 12 Upsets
The college football playoff race was turned upside down on Saturday, as two of the top ten teams in the country lost in overtime on the same afternoon. Number eight Indiana fell 27-24 to Washington in overtime in Seattle, and number four UCLA saw its perfect season end with an 18-16 triple-overtime defeat at Michigan. Oregon, which had already done its work on Friday night with a 45-7 rout of Michigan State, watched the chaos unfold from home and woke up on Sunday as one of the biggest winners of the weekend. The results scrambled the Big Ten championship race, reshaped the projected twelve-team playoff field, and set up a final week of the regular season in which almost everything is still to be decided.
It was the kind of Saturday that reminds everyone why the sport resists prediction. Indiana arrived in Seattle as the defending national champion, ranked eighth by the College Football Playoff selection committee and holding the inside track to the Big Ten championship game. UCLA arrived in Ann Arbor undefeated at ten wins and no losses, ranked fourth, and seemingly on course for a first-round bye in the playoff. Neither team left with a win. By the end of the night, eight teams were still mathematically alive in the Big Ten title race, and the committee's next set of rankings, due on Tuesday, will have to sort through a pile of results that nobody saw coming.
College Football News: Washington Stuns Indiana in Overtime
The biggest domino of the day fell in Seattle, where Washington beat Indiana 27-24 in overtime to hand the Hoosiers their second loss of the season. The Huskies forced the extra period, then opened overtime with a 46-yard field goal from Tyler Robles to take the lead. Indiana's own overtime possession stalled badly, gaining only six yards, and kicker Paddy McAteer's 37-yard attempt to extend the game sailed wide. The miss ended it, and Washington players poured onto the field at Husky Stadium while Indiana's players stood and watched a season that had looked so promising slip further from their control.
The defeat was Indiana's first loss to an unranked opponent all season, and it arrived at the worst possible moment. The Hoosiers entered the weekend at nine wins and one loss, firmly positioned inside the projected playoff bracket and in control of their own path to the Big Ten championship game in Indianapolis. Now they are nine and two, and they no longer control their own destiny. Their route to the conference title game now requires them to beat Purdue in the season finale, and to get help from Washington against Oregon and from Nebraska against Iowa. A loss to Purdue next week would almost certainly knock the defending champions out of the picture altogether.
There were bright spots for Indiana amid the disappointment. Receiver Charlie Becker caught six passes for 167 yards and a touchdown, taking him past one thousand receiving yards for the season and making him only the eighth player in program history to reach that mark in a single campaign. It was a performance worthy of a winning cause, and it underlined how much talent this Indiana team still has. But the offense as a whole could not find the points it needed when the game tightened. Washington quarterback Demond Williams and the Huskies offense gashed a Hoosier defense that had looked vulnerable at times all season, and the committee, which had already been less enthusiastic about Indiana than about the teams around it, now has a clear reason to move the Hoosiers down again.
The loss also changes the way Indiana's season will be judged if the team cannot recover. The Hoosiers won a national championship last season, a triumph that transformed the program's standing in the sport. This year they have looked shaky at times despite winning nearly all of their games, and the doubts that followed them through the autumn have now been given substance by a defeat on the road to an unranked team. The margin for error is gone, and the Hoosiers will spend the final week of the regular season scoreboard-watching as much as they spend it preparing for Purdue.
College Football Rankings: UCLA's Perfect Season Ends in Triple Overtime
If Indiana's loss was the biggest domino, UCLA's was the loudest. The Bruins, ranked fourth in the country and the only remaining undefeated team in the Big Ten, lost 18-16 to Michigan in triple overtime at the Big House. It was a defensive struggle from start to finish, the kind of game in which every yard felt earned and every mistake felt fatal. Michigan's defense, superb all afternoon, held the Bruins in check long enough for the Wolverines to survive three extra periods and hand UCLA its first defeat of the season.
The loss was costly in more ways than one. UCLA also lost quarterback Ty Dieffenbach to what appeared to be a serious injury during the game, and he was carted off the field. Dieffenbach had himself only taken over the job earlier in the season after starter Nico Iamaleava suffered a torn left anterior cruciate ligament, and his departure leaves the offense in the hands of third-string quarterback Madden Iamaleava going forward. The Bruins now face their rivalry game against USC next week with their quarterback room down to its third option, and the selection committee will be watching closely to see how the offense functions without the player who had steadied it.
UCLA remains in control of its own path to the Big Ten championship game despite the defeat, because it is still the conference's only one-loss team. Beat USC, and the Bruins are in the title game regardless of what happens elsewhere. But the bigger question is what the committee will do with a team that started the season ten and zero and now looks like a different outfit without its starting quarterback. The Bruins' resume has been questioned all season: they own just one marquee win, over Oregon. A loss to USC next week, or even an unconvincing win, could leave UCLA on the outside of the playoff field, a remarkable fall for a team that was undefeated in late November.
College Football Playoff Race: Oregon Is Suddenly Back in Control
No team benefited more from Saturday's results than Oregon. The Ducks had already handled their business on Friday night, dominating Michigan State 45-7 for a fourth consecutive win to improve to eight wins and three losses. It was a complete performance, and it included a fake field goal at the end of the first half that worked perfectly, a piece of daring that head coach Dan Lanning pointed to as evidence that his team had rediscovered its aggressive, creative identity. The Ducks had been written off by many observers in the middle of the season after a third loss, including a defeat to Illinois. Lanning changed offensive play callers, promised to get back to being his aggressive self instead of playing it too safe, and the results since then have been emphatic.
Oregon entered the weekend ranked thirteenth in the College Football Playoff rankings, just outside the projected twelve-team field, and needing help from the teams ahead of it. Saturday delivered that help in abundance. The Ducks are now in the Big Ten championship game if the game were played today, and they control their own path to Indianapolis: beat Washington next week, and they are in the title game, where a win would guarantee a place in the playoff. The task is not simple, because Washington has just beaten the defending national champions and will be full of confidence, but the position is one Oregon could scarcely have dreamed of a month ago.
The Ducks' case to the committee has strengthened with every passing week. They own three wins over top-twenty opponents, they have won four games in a row, and they have done it with an offense that looks transformed from the unit that stumbled through the middle of the season. Lanning's team is very much in the mix for the playoff now, either as the potential Big Ten champion or as an at-large selection. There is also a symmetry to Oregon's position that the sport's followers will appreciate: the Ducks' only marquee defeat this season came against UCLA, the team they would meet in the Big Ten championship game if the current standings hold. First, though, Oregon must beat a Washington team that has just proved it can beat anyone on its day.
Who Won the Game Last Night? The Rest of Week 12
The chaos was not confined to the top of the rankings. Ohio State, the preseason number one team in the country, lost 31-28 to unranked Nebraska on the road, a fourth defeat of the season and the first time the Buckeyes have lost four games in a single season in fifteen years. Ohio State lost its starting quarterback in mid-October, but the season has fallen apart because the defense has collapsed, and there is no kinder way to describe a campaign that began with championship expectations and will now end without a conference title or a playoff place. The Buckeyes are the most disappointing team in the country this season, and the Nebraska defeat confirmed a decline that had been building for weeks.
Elsewhere in the Big Ten, Iowa stayed in the hunt by beating Illinois 34-17, shutting out the Fighting Illini in the second half to keep its own championship hopes alive. Rutgers produced one of the stories of the day, beating Penn State 25-24 for its first win at Penn State in nearly forty years. Wisconsin beat Purdue 42-10, and Minnesota edged Northwestern 20-17. Taken together, the results left eight teams still in the race for Indianapolis, a number that tells its own story about how unpredictable this conference has become.
AP Top 25 Poll: What the New Rankings Will Mean
The new College Football Playoff rankings, released on Tuesday, will be the first official attempt to make sense of Week 12, and they will matter more than most weekly updates. UCLA's fall will be the headline number: the Bruins entered the weekend ranked fourth, and the committee must now decide how far a team should drop after losing in triple overtime on the road while also losing its quarterback. Indiana's fall will be nearly as closely watched, because the Hoosiers were already ranked lower than their record suggested. Oregon's rise will be the counterweight, with the Ducks expected to climb into the projected field for the first time in weeks.
The Associated Press Top 25 poll will move in the same direction, but it is the committee's rankings that decide who plays in January. The committee values strength of schedule, quality wins, and the way teams are playing in November, and on all three measures Oregon's case has improved while Indiana's and UCLA's have weakened. For the teams on the edge of the field, the final week of the regular season is now a series of elimination games, and the teams that win convincingly will have the strongest argument when the final rankings are set.
What Happens Next: Rivalry Week Decides Everything
The final week of the regular season, rivalry week, now carries more weight than it has in years. UCLA hosts USC with the Big Ten championship game on the line and its playoff hopes in the balance. Oregon travels to Washington to face the team that ended Indiana's title hopes, knowing that a win puts the Ducks in Indianapolis and a loss could end their season. Indiana hosts Purdue in a rivalry game that the Hoosiers must win to have any hope of a playoff place, and they will be watching the scoreboards from Seattle and Lincoln as they play. Iowa travels to Nebraska needing a win and help from elsewhere to reach the title game.
The paths are clear enough to state plainly. UCLA reaches the championship game by beating USC. Oregon reaches it by beating Washington. Iowa reaches it by beating Nebraska while Oregon loses to Washington or UCLA loses to USC. Indiana reaches it by beating Purdue while Washington beats Oregon and Iowa loses to Nebraska. USC, the longest shot of all, needs to beat UCLA while Nebraska beats Iowa, Purdue beats Indiana, and Washington beats Oregon. Every one of those games will be played with the knowledge that the result could decide a championship and a playoff place, and that is exactly what the final week of the season is supposed to feel like. Week 12 proved that nothing in this sport is settled until the final whistle of the final game, and rivalry week is now set up to prove it all over again.
Source: CBS Sports