Trump Tariffs: Top Democrat Urges Carney to Take Deal
A leading Democrat has told Canada to take the deal on the table now and fight for a better one later, as the trump tariffs standoff between Washington and Ottawa enters its most consequential stretch. Senator Chris Coons of Delaware, speaking to Canadian television this week, urged Prime Minister Mark Carney to accept an interim agreement with President Donald Trump that would bring down the steepest American tariffs on Canadian goods, and to leave the bigger fight to the new Congress that takes office in January. Canadian negotiators are pressing for relief before the end of the year, Trump is threatening to raise auto tariffs to 50 per cent on January 1, and Democrats who swept the midterms are promising to take on the tariffs themselves. For Carney, the choice is between a partial deal now and a gamble on what a new Congress can deliver later.
Coons made the case in an interview with CBC's Power & Politics, telling host David Cochrane that an interim arrangement would be worth taking even if it left some American duties in place. His argument was blunt and practical: lock in whatever relief is available now, and let the incoming Democratic majority legislate a stronger, longer-term settlement.
Trump Tariffs: What Coons Told Canada
The centrepiece of Coons' advice was the set of 50 per cent tariffs imposed in August under a separate American law, known as Section 338, which hit a wide range of Canadian exports after trade talks between the two countries collapsed. Coons told CBC that if Canada can get rid of the 338 tariffs, that would be a significant accomplishment, a judgment that captures how much weight Ottawa itself puts on removing those duties. The Canadian government has made their elimination the core demand of its push for an interim deal, and Coons' endorsement gives that demand a prominent American voice.
Coons went further in a separate interview with CBC Radio's The House, where he said removing tariffs on Canadian goods is his goal as well, while acknowledging that the view might not be shared among all Democrats. Some Democratic lawmakers from steel-producing states, he conceded, would likely favour keeping tariffs on Canadian steel and aluminum, a reminder that the politics of trade inside the Democratic Party are far from uniform.
On the longer-standing sectoral duties, Coons was unsparing. Section 232 tariffs, he said, are justified based on alleged national security threats, and for the United States to impose and maintain them on Canadian imports is an insult to Canada. They should be removed, he said. The duties rest on a claim that imports of steel, aluminum, autos and lumber threaten American national security, a claim Canadian officials have long called absurd when applied to a close ally and the United States' largest trading partner.
Tariff News: What an Interim Deal Would Cover
Canada's own negotiators confirmed this week that an interim deal is now the target. Trade Minister Dominic LeBlanc told Power & Politics on Thursday that the government is seeking an arrangement under which the Section 232 tariffs covering steel, aluminum, autos and lumber would be lowered, and the Section 338 tariffs would be removed entirely. Sources told CBC News the government aims to reach the arrangement by the end of the year, though LeBlanc stressed that is not a hard deadline. The idea is to get the best deal we can get for Canada as soon as possible, he said, adding that if it takes until January or February to get that deal, we will do that work.
The shape of the deal taking form is a compromise on both sides. Ottawa would drop its counter-tariffs, and Washington would remove or reduce the 50 per cent levies and trim the longer-standing 232 duties. LeBlanc said the goal is to reduce the 232 tariffs to a point where Canadian industries could compete globally. An interim agreement would likely still carry some tariffs on the 232 sectors, but at lower rates, and it would likely kickstart formal talks around reviewing the Canada-U.S.-Mexico Agreement, known as CUSMA.
The biggest sticking point, according to sources briefed by the federal government, is the 25 per cent American tariff on Canadian vehicles. Labour leaders, parts manufacturers and automakers operating in Canada have told Ottawa that a 15 per cent tariff would cripple the industry, and the sector is already under strain, with thousands of automotive-related jobs lost and thousands more at risk. Canada's chief trade negotiator, Janice Charette, told members of Parliament that the goal is the lowest rate of tariff on the narrowest basket of goods with the most preferential access for Canadian businesses and Canadian workers.
Hanging over the talks is Trump's threat to raise duties on Canadian automobiles, auto parts and steel to 50 per cent on January 1, a deadline now about six weeks away. The federal government is trying to get a deal on steel, auto and aluminum tariffs before then, but the United States has not filed any formal notice about the threat, which the president made in a social media post in August. The absence of a formal notice leaves the industry in limbo, planning for a blow that may or may not arrive.
Democratic Party News: The Midterm Opening
The reason Coons can promise a better deal later is the midterm elections, in which Democrats are set to take control of both chambers of the United States Congress in January. Several Democrats have identified the tariffs on Canada as an early target. The victory has already changed the conversation in Ottawa, where the question is now whether to sign a deal with the Trump administration or wait to see what the new Congress can do.
Senator Ron Wyden of Oregon, who is poised to chair the Senate Finance Committee when Democrats take control in January, has identified Trump's tariffs on Canada as an early target for repeal. Michigan Senator-elect Abdul El-Sayed, a Democrat, said on Thursday that he was willing to work with Trump on stopping these stupid tariffs with Canada. Senate Democratic leader Chuck Schumer introduced legislation in September aimed at repealing Trump's tariffs, including the duties imposed on Canadian goods. The legislative route, however, faces a hard limit: Trump retains broad authority over trade policy and could veto legislation repealing the tariffs, and Democrats would need substantial Republican support to override a veto.
Carney welcomed the Democratic push after the midterm victory, saying in Winnipeg that restoring free trade would lower costs for American families and benefit American workers. We welcome any moves to restore a free trading arrangement between Canada and the United States, which is in the interests of American families struggling with affordability, he told reporters. He also said he had not spoken with Wyden or other Democrats about potential legislation to eliminate the tariffs.
Inside Canada, the choice between dealing now and waiting has divided even the experts. Roy Norton, a former Canadian diplomat who served as consul general in Chicago and Detroit, has argued that Carney should wait to see whether the new Congress can eliminate tariffs through legislation, saying that striking a deal now that locks in a base tariff would be unnecessary and maybe even foolish. But David Cohen, who served as the American ambassador to Canada under former president Joe Biden, told a House of Commons committee that he expects a deal soon and warned Canadians not to count on the new Congress to reverse Trump's tariffs. Carney himself, speaking in Montreal on November 10, said the American president and his administration, not lawmakers, will decide trade agreements for the next two or three years.
White House News: Trump's 'Fair Deal' and the January 1 Deadline
Trump weighed in on Friday at a White House news conference after returning from his trip to Asia, saying the United States and Canada are working toward a trade agreement that is fair, while cautioning that more work remains. While more work remains to be done with Canada, Prime Minister Carney was very nice, he told reporters. The two leaders had met on November 18 in Shenzhen, China, on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation summit, a meeting that lasted just under twenty minutes. Carney's office said the leaders agreed to continue the work and to stay in close contact.
Trump also repeated his long-standing complaints about the trading relationship, saying Canada has been ripping the United States off for years and is feeling emboldened, and adding that his country does not need Canadian energy, vehicles or lumber. He said he would be ready to talk once Canada's trade surplus with the United States is down to zero, and he noted that Carney wants to build a Keystone pipeline for the United States. Trump said on November 1 that a potential trade agreement with Canada would include Keystone XL. The American goods trade deficit with Canada was 48.3 billion dollars in 2025, according to the Office of the United States Trade Representative.
Carney, speaking at the New York Times DealBook Summit on Wednesday from Shenzhen, said a very, very good trade arrangement is possible but added that his government is not yet there. He made clear that Canada would not sign an agreement that harms its economy, and that if the United States does not want to do a deal, his country is busy building trade ties elsewhere. We would like to do a deal, he said. If the US does not want to do a deal, we are busy. Governor Tiff Macklem, once Carney's deputy at the central bank, said Trump likes to threaten and likes to escalate, but that the two countries were pretty close to a trade deal.
What Happens Next
The next six weeks will decide whether the interim deal Coons is urging actually materialises. Ottawa's negotiators are working toward an arrangement by the end of the year, with January or February as the fallback, and the January 1 auto tariff threat gives both sides a reason to move. If a deal is reached, it would bring down the steepest duties, keep some tariffs in place at lower rates, and open the formal review of CUSMA. If it is not, Canadian exporters face the prospect of 50 per cent duties on vehicles and parts.
Carney has also made clear that Canada is not putting all of its hopes on Washington. He said Canada may consider automakers from Europe and Asia, including China, if trade talks with the United States do not succeed, and in Shenzhen he pitched Chinese President Xi Jinping on a global body to monitor artificial intelligence risks. What to watch is whether the interim deal lands before the January 1 deadline, what level the auto tariff settles at, and whether the new Democratic Congress, once seated in January, moves quickly on legislation to repeal the tariffs or finds its ambitions blocked by a presidential veto.
Source: Newsweek