Politics

Election Results: Texas House Win Challenged in Court

The election results in a Fort Worth-area race for the Texas House have produced one of the strangest postelection disputes of the year. Democrat Ericka Lomick won two elections for the same seat on November 3, a special election and a general election, even though she had suspended her campaign in September after questions were raised about whether she was legally eligible to serve. Now her defeated Republican opponent, Alan Blaylock, has asked the Texas Supreme Court to block her from taking office, arguing that felony convictions from 2011 make her ineligible under Texas law. Governor Greg Abbott has refused to certify her win, and the court has been weighing an emergency filing since Monday evening, leaving the seat in limbo and the district without a settled representative.

The dispute has created an unusual scenario in which the winner of a legislative race could be prevented from taking office despite receiving the most votes. If the court sides with Blaylock, the seat would fall vacant and a new special election would have to be called. If it sides with Lomick, she would take a seat in a historically conservative district that her party had not expected to win, carried there by a Democratic wave that swept the country in the 2026 midterms. Either way, the case will test how Texas handles a question its laws answer only in part: when, if ever, does a person convicted of a felony regain the right to hold public office?

Midterm Elections 2026: A Winner Who Had Already Quit

The 2026 midterms put two races for the same seat on the same ballot, and Lomick won both of them. The district's previous representative, conservative Republican Nate Schatzline, resigned effective July 3, creating a vacancy that required a special election to fill the remainder of the term through January. At the same time, voters also chose a representative for the next full two-year term, which begins when the legislature convenes in January. Lomick won both contests.

Advertisement

According to the court petition filed by Blaylock's lawyers, she received 39,346 votes, or 51.1 percent, in the special election, and 38,972 votes, or 50.5 percent, in the general election. The district covers far north Fort Worth, Blue Mound, Haslet and parts of Saginaw, in Tarrant County. The general-election margin was fewer than 1,000 votes, a narrow win in a district that has long voted Republican, and one that nobody in either party had predicted when the campaign began.

The result was part of a much larger story. The 2026 midterm elections delivered a blue wave that carried Democrats into seats across the country, including both chambers of Congress and several governorships, and the Texas House District 93 race was one of its most unlikely products. Cal Jillson, a political scientist at Southern Methodist University in Dallas, told Newsweek that the dispute was also a striking illustration of that wave, sweeping Democrats into offices that in other electoral cycles would have gone down without notice. The district itself had been regarded as safely Republican, which is why Lomick's victory, by a candidate who had already withdrawn from the race, drew national attention the moment the votes were counted.

What made the win so extraordinary was the sequence of events that came before it. Lomick had won her primary and was campaigning for the seat when a political action committee supporting Blaylock, Protect and Serve Texas, raised questions about her eligibility, accusing her of federal convictions, unpaid taxes and deceptive statements, and published records of a felony conviction from a federal mortgage fraud case in North Carolina. Lomick later confirmed the conviction. On September 21, she announced she was ending her run for office. "After questions arose about the candidate's eligibility to serve as the district's elected Representative, Ericka Lomick has chosen to step aside and allow the people of HD 93 to elect someone who can serve the district without the burden of defending against attacks that would threaten to derail the business of the people," her campaign said in a statement at the time.

Advertisement

She stayed on the ballot anyway. Under Texas election rules, a candidate who withdraws that close to an election remains listed, and voters cast their ballots for her in large numbers. Blaylock, a former Fort Worth City Council member, was the only other candidate on the ballot, and by the account of his own supporters he was the only eligible candidate in the race. The voters chose Lomick regardless, in both contests, and the result has been contested ever since.

The 2011 Case Behind the Challenge

The legal fight turns on events from 15 years ago. Ericka L. Flood, also known as Ericka Lomick, pleaded guilty in federal court in North Carolina in 2011 to mortgage fraud conspiracy, bank fraud and conspiracy to commit money laundering, according to court records attached to the petition filed with the Texas Supreme Court. The records show she received a sentence of 63 months in federal prison, followed by three years of supervised release.

Lomick later asked to have her sentence vacated, arguing that she had received ineffective assistance of counsel, but a federal district judge denied the motion in 2012. The conviction itself has never been overturned, and Lomick has never been pardoned, a point Blaylock has repeated in his public statements about the case. "She pleaded guilty to three federal felonies, mortgage fraud, money laundering, and bank fraud. She's never been pardoned," he said in a Facebook post on Wednesday afternoon.

Advertisement

The petition also raises the question of restitution. It cites a federal restitution lien recorded in Tarrant County in 2024 and references court filings indicating that nearly 290,000 dollars in restitution remained unpaid. Blaylock put the figure higher in his public comments, saying the federal government had put a 300,000 dollar lien on her home two years ago to collect the restitution she owes her victims. The question of whether the money has been repaid matters because, under the reading of Texas law advanced by Blaylock's lawyers, a former felon generally must have completed their sentence, satisfied restitution obligations and had their rights restored before becoming eligible to hold office.

Texas law generally bars a person convicted of a felony from holding public office unless a pardon or a release from the resulting disabilities restores eligibility. Convicted felons are also prohibited from voting in Texas. A 2019 opinion from the Texas attorney general's office said that finishing a sentence does not by itself restore a person's eligibility for office. That opinion is now central to the dispute, because the two sides read its implications very differently.

Democratic Party News: Lomick Insists She Is Qualified

For all the attention on her past, Lomick has maintained throughout that she is eligible to serve, and she has said she intends to take the seat. "I am fully qualified to take the office to which I was elected," she said in a statement reported by the Fort Worth Star-Telegram. "Although I was convicted of a felony in North Carolina many years ago, I was fully released from the resulting disabilities. I am preparing to represent the residents of my district."

Advertisement

Her position appears to rely, in part, on the 2019 attorney general opinion discussed in reporting on the case, which addressed the circumstances under which a person may be eligible to hold office after being released from the hindrances tied to a conviction. Her campaign has confirmed the felony conviction while insisting that she was fully released from the resulting disabilities many years ago. The distinction she is drawing is between the conviction itself, which stands, and the legal disabilities that flowed from it, which she says have been lifted.

That argument has not persuaded Blaylock's side, and it has not yet been tested in court. No state or county official has ruled on her eligibility. The question is now before the Texas Supreme Court, and the answer will turn on how the justices read the constitution, the election code and the attorney general's guidance together. For Democrats, the case is an awkward one: a win delivered by the midterm wave now depends on a legal argument about a candidate's criminal record, in a race the party had not expected to contest seriously once she withdrew.

Republican Party News: Blaylock Asks the Court to Act

Blaylock moved quickly after the election. On Friday, his lawyers sent a letter to Texas Secretary of State Robert S. Howden asking him to declare Lomick ineligible, and asked for an answer by noon on Monday. The same day, the Tarrant County Commissioners Court voted 3-0 to canvass the results of the election, certifying the vote totals without making any finding on Lomick's eligibility. Under normal circumstances, that canvass would have passed the decision on to the Texas House of Representatives, which has the power under the state constitution to determine the eligibility of its own members.

Advertisement

Blaylock's filing may change that. On Monday evening, his lawyers filed an emergency petition with the Texas Supreme Court, asking the court to order Secretary of State Howden to perform a post-election eligibility review and declare Lomick ineligible under Texas Election Code Section 145.003. The filing also asks the court to preserve its jurisdiction by temporarily preventing any certificate of election from being issued that would declare Lomick the winner. The petition seeks relief relating to the special election, though it notes that the same eligibility question is expected to arise regarding the general-election victory.

James E. "Trey" Trainor III, the attorney representing Blaylock, told Newsweek that he does not believe Lomick regained eligibility to hold public office under Texas law. He said the court received the emergency filing on Monday evening. "The mandamus issue is just pending in front of the court," he said. Trainor also said Abbott's office had indicated it would not move forward with certification of the special-election result until the court acts.

Trainor was careful to say the challenge is not an attempt to award the seat to the Republican candidate. "If she is declared ineligible, what that means is that the seat is vacant, and that the governor would have to order a special election," he told Newsweek. That distinction matters, because Blaylock is not asking the court to declare him the winner. He is asking it to declare Lomick ineligible, which would leave the seat empty and send the voters of District 93 back to the polls.

Advertisement

Blaylock himself has been more direct in public. In his Wednesday Facebook post, he said Lomick had sworn on her ballot application that she had never been convicted of a felony, a claim his campaign has made but which has not been independently verified in the reporting on the case. "Texas law is clear: a convicted felon who hasn't been pardoned can't hold this office," he wrote. "Her own campaign admitted in September that there were questions about whether she could serve. Rules apply to everyone. When the Court follows the law, the voters of House District 93 will have the chance to elect someone who can legally serve and get to work on lowering costs for families here."

Trainor, for his part, sounded optimistic about the court's interest in the case. "The fact that we've gone now 24 hours and have not heard anything, that tells me that there's some serious consideration being done by the Supreme Court, and that we'll probably see some sort of written order," he said. The candidates are awaiting a response from the court, and Blaylock said on Wednesday that the court is reviewing the case.

Election Results: What Happens Next

The clock is already working against a quick resolution. November 17 was the deadline for the Secretary of State to certify the votes, and some races were close enough to fall within the margin for a recount. Abbott refused to certify Lomick's win on Tuesday. His press secretary, Andrew Mahaleris, explained the decision to The Center Square: "Before the election, Ericka Lomick suspended her campaign for the Texas House of Representatives after questions arose regarding a prior felony conviction that could make her ineligible. A legal challenge is currently pending in state court to address her eligibility. Given the uncertainty surrounding Lomick's eligibility, Governor Abbott will await guidance from courts about whether she is legally qualified to serve and whether she may be issued a certificate of election."

Advertisement

A spokesperson for Abbott gave the same message to other outlets, saying the governor will await guidance from the courts about whether Lomick is legally qualified to serve and whether she may be issued a certificate of election. When The Center Square asked how Lomick could have registered with the Secretary of State's office to run for office, and whether she was a registered voter, the Secretary of State's office did not respond.

The decisive legal question, as Jillson put it to Newsweek, is relatively straightforward. "Under the Texas Constitution and laws, the most critical question facing the courts is simple: Has Ericka Lomick been pardoned or otherwise released from the restrictions attendant to her North Carolina felony convictions?" If the answer is no, her election cannot stand. If the answer is yes, because a court released her from the disabilities tied to the conviction, then the voters' choice stands and she takes her seat.

Even a court ruling may not be the end of the story, because the two elections point to two different decision-makers. The petition before the Supreme Court covers only the special election, for the unexpired term that runs through January. For the full two-year term that begins in January, the Texas Constitution gives the decision to the legislature itself. Article III, Section 8 makes each house the judge of the qualifications and election of its own members, so whatever the Supreme Court does with Monday's petition, the 150 members of the Texas House will have the final say on whether Lomick takes the District 93 seat when the 90th Legislature convenes in January.

Advertisement

If the court or the House determines that Lomick is not eligible, a new election will be needed. Either Abbott would schedule a special election, or Governor-elect Gina Hinojosa would do so after she is sworn into office next year. Until then, the district's voters are left waiting on a court that has given no timetable, a governor who has declined to certify the result, and a winning candidate who insists she is ready to serve. The case is a reminder that in Texas, winning the most votes is sometimes only the beginning of the fight over who gets to hold office.

Source: The New York Times

Advertisement
Advertisement

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Advertisement
Advertisement
About Us  |  Contact Us  |  Privacy Policy  |  Disclaimer  |  Terms and Conditions