DOJ News: Trump Presses U.S. Attorneys Fight in Court
The doj news from Washington this week carries a blunt message: the Trump administration is pressing ahead in its legal battle over the country's top federal prosecutors, even as judges keep ruling against it. In Virginia, the prosecutor at the center of the fight, Lindsey Halligan, has left her post after a federal judge declared her appointment unlawful and threw out the two highest-profile indictments she brought. In New Jersey, another former Trump lawyer, Alina Habba, faces a state ethics complaint over her conduct before she joined the administration. And in New York, the administration is defending yet another contested appointment in court. Through it all, the Justice Department has appealed, argued and maneuvered to keep its prosecutors in place, and the fight now heads toward an appeals court and a new Congress.
The stakes reach beyond any single prosecutor. The 93 United States attorneys are the federal government's chief law enforcement officers in their districts, deciding which cases to bring and which investigations to open or close. By law they must be nominated by the president and confirmed by the Senate. The administration has instead filled several of the most prominent posts with interim appointees, then used a series of personnel maneuvers to keep them in place after their temporary terms expired. Federal judges in four states have now ruled those maneuvers unlawful. The administration's response has been to press on: appealing the rulings, contesting the judges' orders and looking for new ways to revive the prosecutions that were thrown out.
The Halligan Case: How the Virginia Fight Began
The trouble began with the way Halligan got the job. Federal law allows the attorney general to appoint an interim United States attorney for 120 days; after that, the district's judges may appoint someone to serve until the vacancy is filled. Halligan was a former personal lawyer to President Donald Trump with no prior experience as a prosecutor when she was installed as interim United States attorney for the Eastern District of Virginia. Her appointment followed the resignation under pressure of the acting United States attorney, Erik Siebert, who had refused to bring charges against former FBI Director James Comey and New York Attorney General Letitia James. Within weeks, Halligan secured indictments against both of them.
Judge Cameron McGowan Currie, sitting by designation in the Eastern District of Virginia, found that the law did not allow the administration to appoint two interim prosecutors in succession, because Siebert had already served as an interim appointee. On November 24, 2025, Currie ruled Halligan's appointment unlawful and dismissed the indictments against Comey and James as the products of a defective appointment. Comey had been charged with lying to Congress and James with lying on mortgage paperwork, and both cases were built on evidence that career prosecutors had viewed as weak, according to people familiar with the matter. The dismissals did not decide whether the underlying allegations were true. They decided that the prosecutor who brought them had no lawful authority to do so.
Attorney General Pam Bondi tried to fix the problem with paperwork, issuing orders on October 31, 2025, November 14, 2025, and January 13, 2026, that purported to appoint Halligan as special attorney retroactive to September 22, 2025, and to ratify her actions. Currie held that none of it cured the defect: the attorney general could not retroactively appoint Halligan to a different office or ratify an indictment obtained by a prosecutor who had never been lawfully appointed. The Justice Department appealed to the Fourth Circuit, filing its brief on March 3, 2026. It did not seek a stay, so the ruling remains in effect while the appeal is pending.
Trump Administration: The Title Fight in Richmond
Even after the ruling, Halligan kept signing court papers as the district's top prosecutor, and the administration kept defending her right to do so. That defiance produced a second confrontation, with Judge David Novak in Richmond, a judge appointed by Trump himself. Novak ordered Halligan to explain in writing why her continued use of the title was not a false or misleading statement, giving her seven days to respond. The Justice Department answered with a filing signed by Halligan herself, arguing that no misrepresentation had occurred. Novak was not persuaded. In an 18-page order, he struck the words United States Attorney from her signature blocks, barred her from using the title in his court and warned that continued use could prompt disciplinary proceedings.
The episode exposed a split inside the department. Senior Justice Department officials had privately decided that because Currie's ruling did not expressly remove Halligan from office, she could remain, according to people familiar with their decision. Internal guidance instructed prosecutors in the district to keep listing Halligan as both United States Attorney and Special United States Attorney on court filings, citing approval from the department's Office of Legal Counsel. The strain broke into the open with the firing of Robert K. McBride, the district's first assistant and Halligan's top deputy, after a disagreement about whether he would take charge of the administration's effort to reindict Comey, according to multiple people familiar with the matter. McBride had served in the district for only a couple of months after more than a decade as a federal prosecutor in Kentucky.
Halligan has now left the interim post altogether, saying she departed after her 120-day appointment expired. The district's chief judge, M. Hannah Lauck, has authorized a vacancy announcement to fill the office. The departure does not end the legal fight: the department is still appealing Currie's ruling and still trying to revive the prosecutions of Comey and James. But it removes the most visible symbol of the administration's approach, a prosecutor installed through an unusual personnel maneuver, defended after a judge voided her appointment and finally gone when the clock on her temporary term ran out.
White House News: The Same Pattern in Four States
Virginia was not the only place where the approach ran into a judge. In New Jersey, a federal judge ruled that Alina Habba, Trump's former personal lawyer, was unlawfully serving as the state's top federal prosecutor, and the Third Circuit upheld that conclusion on December 1, 2025. Habba had been appointed interim United States attorney in March 2025. She resigned on December 8, 2025, and moved into a senior advisory role at the Justice Department, a position she held until earlier this year. Her case followed the same pattern as Halligan's: a loyalist installed without Senate confirmation, a court ruling that the appointment violated the law and a department that fought the ruling rather than accepting it.
Habba is now facing a separate legal problem. On November 11, 2026, the New Jersey Supreme Court's Office of Attorney Ethics filed a 23-page disciplinary complaint against her, arising from a 2021 dispute involving Alice Bianco, then a 21-year-old server at the Trump National Golf Club in Bedminster, who had alleged sexual harassment by her manager. According to the complaint, Habba, a dues-paying member of the club, inserted herself into the matter, persuaded Bianco to drop her lawyer and brokered a 15,000-dollar settlement with the Trump Organization. Bianco later sued the club with a new lawyer, and the matter was eventually resolved with a total settlement of 400,000 dollars. The complaint alleges conflicts of interest and notes that Habba acknowledged in a June 2026 interview with ethics officials that her actions violated New Jersey's rules of professional conduct. Her lawyer, Kim D. Ringler, said no determination has been made and no finding of wrongdoing has been reached, and the allegations will be reviewed by the state's special ethics adjudicator before the state justices decide.
In upstate New York, the same playbook produced the same result. The administration appointed John Sarcone as interim United States attorney for the Northern District of New York in March, and when his 120-day term elapsed, the district's judges declined to keep him in the post. Bondi then appointed Sarcone as a special attorney and designated him first assistant United States attorney, a maneuver federal officials said allowed him to serve as acting United States attorney. Letitia James has challenged his authority in federal court, disputing the legitimacy of subpoenas issued as part of an investigation into regulatory lawsuits she filed against Trump and the National Rifle Association. On the West Coast, the department redesignated interim prosecutors as acting prosecutors just before their terms expired: in Nevada, Sigal Chattah was redesignated a day before her interim term expired, and in Los Angeles, Bill Essayli received the same treatment hours later. Senator Jacky Rosen, Democrat of Nevada, accused the administration of relying on an unconstitutional maneuver to keep Chattah in a job she said would be soundly rejected by both sides of the aisle if she had to face the Senate.
FBI News: Comey and James at the Center of the Case
At the center of the Virginia fight are two prosecutions that were always about more than the charges themselves. Comey, the former FBI director, was indicted on charges of lying to Congress. James was indicted on charges of lying on mortgage paperwork. Both had been targets of the president's anger for years: Comey for the FBI's investigation of Russian interference in the 2016 election, James for the civil fraud case she brought against Trump's business empire. Trump selected Halligan after her predecessor resisted bringing charges against them, saying the evidence was not sufficient to warrant doing so. The indictments were obtained without the participation of career prosecutors, who sources say refused because they viewed the evidence as weak.
The cases illustrate why the administration has fought so hard to keep its appointees. The prosecutors at the center of the dispute were chosen because they were willing to bring cases that career officials would not, and that willingness is what made them valuable to the White House and vulnerable in court. A prosecutor who owes her job to the president's favor, rather than to Senate confirmation, is easier to install and easier to direct, but the law was written to make that arrangement temporary. The 120-day limit exists to force a choice: nominate the person and let the Senate decide, or let the judges choose a replacement.
What Happens Next
The next step belongs to the Fourth Circuit, where the appeal of Currie's ruling is pending. The department's brief argues that the appointment was lawful under the interim-appointment statute and the Appointments Clause, and that the dismissal of the indictments was wrong. Comey's lawyers have answered that the appointment violated the statute's text and that the dismissal was required. No stay has been granted, so Currie's decision remains binding in the Eastern District of Virginia for now, and the department's effort to revive the prosecutions is proceeding without the prosecutor who brought them.
The fight is also about to acquire a new audience. The midterm elections on November 3 gave Democrats control of both chambers of Congress, and the new Congress takes office in January. The Times reported this week that the Justice Department is bracing for fresh fights, with senior officials warning prosecutors that the department is now, in the words of principal associate deputy attorney general Aakash Singh, a wartime department. Singh urged the country's United States attorneys to step up pressure on local officials in Democratic-controlled cities to cooperate with federal immigration enforcement. The department has already lost hundreds of career officials who were forced out or left over the president's priorities, and several senior leaders have departed. The Times also reported that Attorney General Todd Blanche intends to use the department to fight off attempts by Congress to investigate administration officials.
The donald trump latest news on this front, then, is a story of a legal strategy under strain from every direction: judges voiding appointments, prosecutors departing, a new Congress preparing to investigate and an appeals court holding the fate of the two most prominent prosecutions. The administration has shown no sign of backing down. It is appealing the Virginia ruling, contesting the judges' orders, looking for ways to reindict Comey and defending its remaining appointees in court. The question now is whether the courts and the new Congress will let it keep pressing ahead, or whether the string of rulings against it marks the point where the strategy finally runs out of road.
Source: The New York Times