Trump News: Judge Blitz Faces Republican Resistance
A last-minute effort by President Donald Trump to install as many judges as possible before Democrats take control of the United States Senate is running into resistance from some fellow Republicans, Reuters reported on Sunday. The push, unfolding in the final weeks of the lame-duck session, is the closing chapter of a years-long project to reshape the federal judiciary — and it is meeting its stiffest test not from the opposition, but from within the president's own party.
Until recently, Senate Republicans had routinely approved Trump's nominees for lifetime seats on district and appeals courts during his second term, confirming 57 so far and helping him cement a conservative imprint on the judiciary that will outlast his presidency. The pace reflected a party largely united behind the project and a White House determined to move quickly while it held the Senate. But as the White House and Senate Republican leaders press ahead with judicial nominees during the lame-duck session, a handful of Republicans have blocked or cast doubt on three nominees selected for their home states.
The resistance matters because of the calendar. Once Democrats take control of the Senate, the confirmation pipeline that has delivered Trump's judges will narrow sharply, if not close altogether. Every nominee confirmed in the coming weeks is a lifetime appointment — a judge who will sit on the federal bench for decades, deciding cases on everything from business regulation to civil rights to the scope of presidential power. Every nominee who stalls is, in practical terms, a vacancy the next Senate majority will fill on its own terms. That is why the White House has described the coming weeks as a final push, and why the friction inside the Republican conference has drawn so much attention.
Trump News: Three Nominees, Three Problems
The trouble is concentrated in three nominations, each blocked or questioned by Republican senators from the nominees' own home states. The pattern is significant because of an old Senate tradition: home-state senators are given a large say over who is nominated to federal courts in their states, and when they object, their colleagues usually listen. That tradition, known as senatorial courtesy, has survived for generations precisely because senators of both parties want the same deference when the roles are reversed.
Two outgoing Republican members of the Senate Judiciary Committee, Thom Tillis of North Carolina and John Cornyn of Texas, can deny such nominees the votes needed to advance. Both are leaving the Senate, which gives them unusual freedom: they do not face re-election, they do not need the White House's help with future campaigns, and they have little to lose by standing in the way of a nomination they oppose. Their leverage is real, and the White House knows it.
The clearest example came earlier in the week, when the White House took the rare step of withdrawing the nomination of United States District Judge Lee Rudofsky to the St. Louis-based 8th United States Circuit Court of Appeals. The withdrawal followed opposition from Arkansas Senators John Boozman and Tom Cotton, who objected to Rudofsky's selection. In his place, the administration named Arkansas Supreme Court Justice J. Cody Hiland — a choice the home-state senators found acceptable. The swap resolved one standoff, but it also demonstrated the price of moving quickly without first securing home-state support: a public reversal, a lost week, and a reminder to every other senator that objections work.
Cornyn has separately declined to commit to supporting T. Elliot Gaiser, Trump's nominee for a federal judgeship in Dallas. The refusal to commit is itself a signal. In the normal course of confirmations, a home-state senator's support is treated as a given once a nomination is announced. When that support is withheld, the nomination stalls, and the White House must decide whether to fight, negotiate or withdraw. With the clock running on the lame-duck session, each of those options costs time the administration can ill afford.
Senate Republicans and the Lame-Duck Calendar
Senate Majority Leader John Thune said on Monday that judicial confirmations were a top priority while Republicans retain control of the chamber. The Senate confirmed its first judicial nominee of the lame-duck session on Thursday. Twenty-three nominees remain pending, including Colorado-based United States District Judge Daniel Domenico, whose nomination to the Denver-based 10th United States Circuit Court of Appeals is set for a Monday vote.
The arithmetic of the lame-duck session is unforgiving. Each confirmation consumes floor time, and floor time is the Senate's scarcest resource in the final weeks of a session, when spending bills, defense authorization and a stack of other unfinished business all compete for the same hours. Thune's decision to prioritize judges signals how the leadership values the project, but it also means every stalled nomination costs time that could have been spent confirming someone else. The White House's public line reflects that urgency. "We expect all judicial nominees pending in the Senate to be confirmed this year," a White House official said in a statement — a confident prediction that the coming weeks will now test.
The stakes extend beyond the 23 pending nominees. Each confirmation adds to a total that already shapes the judiciary for a generation. Trump made 234 judicial appointments during his first term in office from 2017 to 2021, including three members of the Supreme Court's current 6-3 conservative supermajority. The second-term confirmations, 57 so far, extend that record. Together, the two terms represent one of the most consequential remakings of the federal bench in modern American history, and the lame-duck push is its final installment.
How a Nomination Becomes a Judge
The path from nomination to confirmation is deliberately slow, and the lame-duck session compresses it. A nominee is first vetted by the White House and the Justice Department, then formally nominated to the Senate, where the Judiciary Committee holds a hearing and votes on whether to send the nomination to the full Senate. Only then does the Majority Leader bring it to the floor, where a simple majority is enough to confirm. That simple-majority rule is itself the product of two rule changes: in 2013, Democrats lowered the threshold for lower-court nominees from 60 votes to 51, and in 2017, Republicans did the same for Supreme Court nominees. The filibuster no longer protects judicial nominees, which is why the majority party can move quickly when it is united — and why a handful of dissenters can still gum up the works by withholding the committee votes or the home-state support a nomination needs to advance.
The home-state tradition that is now causing trouble has a formal expression in the blue-slip process, under which the Judiciary Committee asks both home-state senators for their views on a nominee. A negative blue slip does not automatically kill a nomination, but chairs of both parties have generally treated it as a serious obstacle, particularly for district court seats. Tillis and Cornyn sit on the committee itself, which gives them a second lever: they can vote against advancing a nominee out of committee, denying the White House the votes it needs at the very first step. That dual leverage — home-state senator and committee member — is what makes their resistance so difficult to overcome in the few weeks remaining.
Why the Judiciary Project Matters So Much
For the White House, the next few weeks reflect the last hurrah on a project that began during Trump's first administration to shift the federal judiciary's ideological balance to the right, an initiative whose effects will be felt for years after Trump leaves office. Federal judges serve for life, and their rulings shape the law long after the presidents who appointed them have gone. A judge confirmed this month could still be deciding cases in the 2050s, on questions no one in today's politics has yet imagined.
The project has always been about more than individual nominees. It is about the direction of the courts on the issues that divide American politics most sharply: the power of federal agencies to regulate business, the scope of gun rights, the balance between religious liberty and anti-discrimination law, the authority of the president himself. Conservative legal groups have treated judicial selection as their highest priority for a decade, building pipelines of young lawyers and judges, and the Trump administration has drawn heavily on those pipelines. The result is a judiciary that is measurably more conservative than the one Trump inherited — and a Democratic Party that regards reversing that shift as one of its own highest priorities.
That is why the lame-duck session matters so much to both sides. For Republicans, every confirmation now is a judge Democrats cannot replace later. For Democrats, every delay is a vacancy they may fill themselves once they hold the Senate. The resistance from Tillis, Cornyn, Boozman and Cotton is therefore doubly frustrating to the White House: it is not the opposition slowing the project down, but members of the president's own party, exercising a prerogative the Senate has honored for more than a century.
What Happens Next
The immediate test comes on Monday, when the Senate is set to vote on Judge Domenico's nomination to the 10th Circuit. A smooth confirmation would suggest the machinery is still working and the White House's confidence is justified. A delay or a narrow margin would suggest the opposite — that the lame-duck push is running into the same friction that has already cost the administration one nomination this week.
Beyond Monday, the White House faces a series of choices about the remaining nominees. It can negotiate with the objecting senators, offering concessions or alternative nominees, as it did in the Rudofsky case. It can press ahead and dare the objectors to vote against a fellow Republican's nominee on the floor — a confrontation that would consume time and political capital. Or it can quietly let the most contested nominations slide, concentrating its remaining floor time on the nominees who can move without a fight. Each option has costs, and the administration has only weeks to choose.
The broader lesson of the week is that even the most disciplined party project meets resistance at the edges, and that the Senate's traditions — senatorial courtesy, the blue-slip process, the deference owed to home-state senators — still shape outcomes even in an era of intense partisanship. Trump reshaped the judiciary more than any president in a generation. Whether the final weeks of his second term add a few dozen more judges to that legacy, or only a handful, will depend on negotiations happening now, behind closed doors, between a White House in a hurry and senators who are in no rush at all.
Source: Reuters